No Items in Cart Civil Docket Report

A $5 Convenience fee will be added to the transaction at checkout.

Case Description   Case ID:  160901452  (Public Case, all documents are free of charge)   Case Caption:  WILLIAMS ETAL VS CITY OF PHILADELPHIA ETAL   Filing Date:  Wednesday, September 14th, 2016   Court:  MAJOR NON JURY EXPEDITED   Location:  CITY HALL   Jury:  NON JURY   Case Type:  EQUITY - NO REAL ESTATE   Status:  ORDER ENTERED - FINAL DISPOS Related Cases No related cases were found. Case Event Schedule No case events were found. Case motions No case motions were found. Case Parties Seq # Assoc Expn Date Type Name 1     ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF LAVELLE JR., JOHN P Address: MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP 2222 MARKET STREET PHILADELPHIA PA 19103 (215)963-4824 john.lavelle@morganlewis.com  Aliases: none   2 1   PLAINTIFF WILLIAMS, LORA JEAN Address: 3416/3418 HAVERFORD AVENUE PHILADELPHIA PA 19104  Aliases: none   3 1   PLAINTIFF PENNSYLVANIA FOOD MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION Address: 1029 MUMMA ROAD WORMLEYSBURG PA 17043  Aliases: none   4 20   DEFENDANT CITY OF PHILADELPHIA Address: ONE PARKWAY BUILDING 17TH FLOOR 1515 ARCH STREET PHILADELPHIA PA 19102  Aliases: none   5 20   DEFENDANT BRESLIN, FRANK Address: MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING 1401 JOHN F. KENNEDY BOULEVARD CONCOURSE LEVEL PHILADELPHIA PA 19102  Aliases: none   6 1   PLAINTIFF SMITH, GREGORY J Address: 825 GRIFFITH STREET PHILADELPHIA PA 19111  Aliases: none   7 1   PLAINTIFF CVP MANAGEMENT INC Address: 1434 CECIL B. MOORE AVENUE PHILADELPHIA PA 19121  Aliases: CITY VIEW PIZZA TDBA   8 1   PLAINTIFF JOHN'S ROAST PORK INC Address: 14 E. SNYDER AVENUE PHILADELPHIA PA 19148  Aliases: JOHN'S ROAST PORK FKA   9 1   PLAINTIFF METRO BEVERAGE OF PHILADELPHIA INC Address: 455 DUNKSFERRY ROAD BENSALEM PA 19020  Aliases: METRO BEVERAGE TDBA   10 1   PLAINTIFF DAY'S BEVERAGES INC Address: 529 GUINEVERE DRIVE NEWTOWN SQUARE PA 19073  Aliases: DAY'S BEVERAGES TDBA   11 1   PLAINTIFF AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION Address: 1275 PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE NW WASHINGTON DC 20004  Aliases: none   12 1   PLAINTIFF PENNSYLVANIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION Address: 204 STATE STREET HARRISBURG PA 17101  Aliases: none   13 1   PLAINTIFF PHILADELPHIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION Address: 1900 MARKET STREET PHILADELPHIA PA 19103  Aliases: none   14 1   ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF SONNENFELD, MARC J Address: MORGAN LEWIS & BOCKIUS 1701 MARKET ST PHILADELPHIA PA 19103 (215)963-5572 marc.sonnenfeld@morganlewis.com  Aliases: none   15 1   ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF SULLIVAN ESQ, THOMAS J Address: SHOOK HARDY & BACON LLP TWO COMMERCE SQUARE 2001 MARKET ST SUITE 3000 PHILADELPHIA PA 19103 (215)278-2555 tsullivan@shb.com  Aliases: none   16 1   ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF SPECTER, SHANIN Address: KLINE & SPECTER 1525 LOCUST ST., 19TH FL. PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 (215)772-1000 shanin.specter@klinespecter.com  Aliases: none   17 1   ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF BECKER, CHARLES L Address: KLINE & SPECTER PC 19TH FLOOR 1525 LOCUST ST PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 (215)772-1394 charles.becker@klinespecter.com  Aliases: none   18 1   ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF PALMER, TRACIE L Address: 1525 LOCUST ST PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 (215)772-1384 tracie.palmer@klinespecter.com  Aliases: none   19   20-SEP-2016 TEAM LEADER DJERASSI, RAMY I Address: Room 300 CITY HALL PHILADELPHIA PA 19107 (215)686-7338  Aliases: none   20     ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT TRUJILLO, KENNETH I Address: 300 CONSHOHOCKEN STATE ROAD SUITE 500 WEST CONSHOHOCKEN PA 19428 (610)772-2340 ktrujillo@chamberlainlaw.com  Aliases: none   21   21-SEP-2016 TEAM LEADER GLAZER, GARY S Address: 469 CITY HALL PHILADELPHIA PA 19107 (215)686-9540  Aliases: none   22     ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT ARONCHICK, MARK A Address: ONE LOGAN SQUARE 27TH FLOOR PHILADELPHIA PA 19103-6933 (215)568-6200 maa@hangley.com  Aliases: none   23 20   ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT STAPLETON, JOHN S Address: LEVAN STAPLETON SEGAL COCHRAN 1760 MARKET STREET SUITE 403 PHILADELPHIA PA 19103 (215)561-1500 jstapleton@levanstapleton.com  Aliases: none   24     TEAM LEADER GLAZER, GARY S Address: 469 CITY HALL PHILADELPHIA PA 19107 (215)686-9540  Aliases: none   25   13-OCT-2016 TEAM LEADER SHIRDAN-HARRIS, LISETTE Address: 516 CITY HALL PHILADELPHIA PA 19107  Aliases: none   26   13-OCT-2016 JUDGE CARPENTER, LINDA Address: 294 CITY HALL PHILADELPHIA PA 19107  Aliases: none   27 20   ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT MAVROUDIS, DIMITRIOS Address: 300 SULLIVAN HALL 1330 W. POLETT WALK PHILADELPHIA PA 19122 (215)869-1432 dmavroudis@temple.edu  Aliases: none   28 20   ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT PRATT, MARCEL S Address: BALLARD SPAHR LLP 1735 MARKET STREET 51ST FLOOR PHILADELPHIA PA 19103 (215)864-8506 prattm@ballardspahr.com  Aliases: none   29 1   ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF WILLIAMS CAP, DAVID C Address: KLINE & SPECTER PC 1525 LOCUST STREET 19THFLOOR PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 (215)772-1000 David.Williams@klinespecter.com  Aliases: none   30 20   ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT OLESH, MATTHEW S Address: OBERMAYER 1500 MARKET ST SUITE 3400 CENTRE SQ W PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 (215)665-3043 matthew.olesh@obermayer.com  Aliases: none Docket Entries Filing Date/Time Docket Type Filing Party Disposition Amount 14-SEP-2016 08:12 AM ACTIVE CASE     Docket Entry: E-Filing Number: 1609027219   14-SEP-2016 08:12 AM COMMENCEMENT OF CIVIL ACTION LAVELLE JR., JOHN P   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Final Cover   Docket Entry: none.   14-SEP-2016 08:12 AM COMPLAINT FILED NOTICE GIVEN LAVELLE JR., JOHN P   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Complaint.pdf Ex. A -Bill No. 16017601.pdf Ex. B- Excerpted Statutes.pdf Ex. C -Declaration and Verification - Lora Williams.pdf Ex. D -Declaration and Verification - Gregory Smith.pdf Ex. E -Declaration and Verification - City View Pizza.pdf Ex. F -Declaration and Verification - Johns Roast Pork.pdf Ex. G -Declaration and Verification - Metro Beverage.pdf Ex. H -Declaration and Verification - Days Beverages.pdf Ex. I -Declaration and Verification - Neely.pdf Ex. J -Declaration and Verification - Pa Bev Assoc.pdf Ex. K -Declaration and Verification - Phila Bev Assoc.pdf Ex. L -Declaration and Verification - PFMA.pdf Ex. M - Mayor Kenney on Smerconish Apr 7 2016.pdf Ex. N - Berkeley BEST study.pdf Ex. O. -Solicitor SSB Opinion.pdf Ex. P -Sales Tax Item List.pdf Commerce Addendum   Docket Entry: COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 1018.1 FILED.   14-SEP-2016 08:12 AM SHERIFF'S SURCHARGE 2 DEFTS LAVELLE JR., JOHN P   Docket Entry: none.   14-SEP-2016 08:12 AM WAITING TO LIST CASE MGMT CONF LAVELLE JR., JOHN P   Docket Entry: none.   14-SEP-2016 12:19 PM ENTRY OF APPEARANCE SONNENFELD, MARC J   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Sonnenfeld and Sullivan Entry of Appearance.pdf   Docket Entry: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF THOMAS J SULLIVAN ESQ AND MARC J SONNENFELD FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PHILADELPHIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, PENNSYLVANIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, DAY'S BEVERAGES, INC., METRO BEVERAGE OF PHILADELPHIA, INC., JOHN'S ROAST PORK, INC., CVP MANAGEMENT, INC., GREGORY J. SMITH, PENNSYLVANIA FOOD MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION AND LORA JEAN WILLIAMS)   14-SEP-2016 12:23 PM ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL SPECTER, SHANIN   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Specter and Becker Entry of Appearance.pdf   Docket Entry: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF CHARLES L BECKER AND SHANIN SPECTER AS CO-COUNSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PHILADELPHIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, PENNSYLVANIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, DAY'S BEVERAGES, INC., METRO BEVERAGE OF PHILADELPHIA, INC., JOHN'S ROAST PORK, INC., CVP MANAGEMENT, INC., GREGORY J. SMITH, PENNSYLVANIA FOOD MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION AND LORA JEAN WILLIAMS)   14-SEP-2016 01:13 PM MISCELLANEOUS MOTION/PETITION LAVELLE JR., JOHN P   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Motion for Leave to File Memo of Law (Case No. 01452).pdf Brief in Support of Motion for Leave to File Memo of Law (Case No. 01452).pdf Proposed Order (Case No. 01452).pdf Exhibit A - Memorandum of Law ISO Declaratory and Injunctive Relief (Case No. 01452).pdf Ex. 1 to Exhibit A -Memo of Law - Complaint with Exhibits (Case No. 01452).pdf Ex. 2 to Exhibit A - Memo of Law - Dietly Expert Report (Case No. 01452).pdf Cert of Service (Case No. 01452).pdf Motion CoverSheet Form   Docket Entry: 63-16092063 RESPONSE DATE 10/04/2016. PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF (FILED ON BEHALF OF PHILADELPHIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, PENNSYLVANIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, DAY'S BEVERAGES, INC., METRO BEVERAGE OF PHILADELPHIA, INC., JOHN'S ROAST PORK, INC., CVP MANAGEMENT, INC., GREGORY J. SMITH, PENNSYLVANIA FOOD MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION AND LORA JEAN WILLIAMS)   16-SEP-2016 10:48 AM ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL PALMER, TRACIE L   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents EOA - TLP.pdf   Docket Entry: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF TRACIE L PALMER AS CO-COUNSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PHILADELPHIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, PENNSYLVANIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, DAY'S BEVERAGES, INC., METRO BEVERAGE OF PHILADELPHIA, INC., JOHN'S ROAST PORK, INC., CVP MANAGEMENT, INC., GREGORY J. SMITH, PENNSYLVANIA FOOD MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION AND LORA JEAN WILLIAMS)   17-SEP-2016 03:08 PM AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FILED     Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Affidavit of Service   Docket Entry: AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE OF COMPLAINT AND ENTRIES OF APPEARANCE UPON CITY OF PHILADELPHIA BY PERSONAL SERVICE ON 09/14/2016 FILED.   19-SEP-2016 02:10 PM ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE FILED     Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents ACCOS_11.pdf   Docket Entry: SERVICE OF EMERGENCY APPLICATION FOR EXTRAORDINARY RELIEF OR THE EXERCISE OF KING'S BENCH POWERS ACCEPTED BY OFFICE OF JUDICIAL RECORDS ON 14-SEP-2016 FILED.   19-SEP-2016 04:32 PM ENTRY OF APPEARANCE TRUJILLO, KENNETH I   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Entry of Appearance.pdf   Docket Entry: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF KENNETH I TRUJILLO FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRANK BRESLIN AND CITY OF PHILADELPHIA)   20-SEP-2016 01:45 PM ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ALLEN, JACQUELINE F   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents ORDER_13.pdf   Docket Entry: AND NOW, THIS 20th DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2016, IT APPEARS THAT THIS CASE DOES NOT FIT THE COMMERCE PROGRAM CRITERIA, HOWEVER, UPON CONSIDERATION OF ALL AVAILABLE JUDICIAL RESOURCES, IT IS ORDERED THAT THIS CASE IS TRANSFERRED TO THE HONORABLE GARY S. GLAZER FOR ALL FURTHER PROCEEDINGS. ... BY THE COURT: ALLEN, J. 9/20/2016   20-SEP-2016 01:45 PM NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236     Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 20-SEP-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 20-SEP-2016.   20-SEP-2016 02:24 PM ENTRY OF APPEARANCE ARONCHICK, MARK A   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents 2016-09-20 City-Breslin EOA - Aronchick-Stapleton.pdf   Docket Entry: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF MARK A ARONCHICK AND JOHN S STAPLETON FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRANK BRESLIN AND CITY OF PHILADELPHIA)   20-SEP-2016 05:48 PM ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE FILED LAVELLE JR., JOHN P   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Acceptance of Service - Breslin.pdf   Docket Entry: SERVICE OF PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT ACCEPTED BY KENNETH I TRUJILLO ON 09/20/2016 FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PHILADELPHIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, PENNSYLVANIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, DAY'S BEVERAGES, INC., METRO BEVERAGE OF PHILADELPHIA, INC., JOHN'S ROAST PORK, INC., CVP MANAGEMENT, INC., GREGORY J. SMITH, PENNSYLVANIA FOOD MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION AND LORA JEAN WILLIAMS)   21-SEP-2016 12:06 PM TRANSFERRED TO MAJOR NON-JURY     Docket Entry: none.   21-SEP-2016 12:07 PM WAITING TO LIST CASE MGMT CONF     Docket Entry: none.   04-OCT-2016 03:01 PM ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED ARONCHICK, MARK A   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents 2016-10-04 - Answer to Motion for Leave .pdf 2016-10-04 - Memo in Opp to Motion for Leave.pdf 2016-10-04 - Proposed Order.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form   Docket Entry: 63-16092063 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MISCELLANEOUS MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRANK BRESLIN AND CITY OF PHILADELPHIA)   06-OCT-2016 10:59 AM MOTION ASSIGNED     Docket Entry: 63-16092063 MISCELLANEOUS MOTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: CARPENTER, LINDA . ON DATE: OCTOBER 06, 2016   07-OCT-2016 02:00 PM ENTRY OF APPEARANCE MAVROUDIS, DIMITRIOS   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Entry of Appearance.pdf   Docket Entry: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF DIMITRIOS MAVROUDIS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRANK BRESLIN AND CITY OF PHILADELPHIA)   07-OCT-2016 02:00 PM CITY CHARGE SUBSEQUENT FILINGS MAVROUDIS, DIMITRIOS   Docket Entry: none.   07-OCT-2016 06:47 PM PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ARONCHICK, MARK A   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents 2016-10-07 - Preliminary Objections.pdf Exhibits 1 - 3.pdf 2016-10-07 - Memorandum in Support of POs.pdf Proposed Order.pdf   Docket Entry: 40-16100940 PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' COMPLAINT FILED. RESPONSE DATE: 10/31/2016 (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRANK BRESLIN AND CITY OF PHILADELPHIA)   13-OCT-2016 09:36 AM MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED     Docket Entry: 63-16092063 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE GLAZER, GARY S ON 13-OCT-16   13-OCT-2016 09:36 AM PREL OBJECT-ASSIGNMENT UPDATED     Docket Entry: 40-16100940 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE GLAZER, GARY S ON 13-OCT-16   14-OCT-2016 10:52 AM PREL OBJECT-RESP DATE UPDATED     Docket Entry: 40-16100940 PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS MOTION RESPONSE DATE UPDATED TO 10/31/2016.   14-OCT-2016 02:46 PM ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents ORDER_27.pdf   Docket Entry: AND NOW, THIS 14TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2016, IT HEREBY IS ORDERED THAT THE PARTIES APPEAR FOR A STATUS CONFERENCE BEFORE THIS COURT ON OCTOBER 25, 2016 AT 10:30 A.M. IN COURTROOM 650 CITY HALL, PHILADELPHIA, PA. 19107. BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 10/14/16.   14-OCT-2016 02:46 PM NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236     Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 14-OCT-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 14-OCT-2016.   14-OCT-2016 02:47 PM LISTED FOR STATUS CONFERENCE     Docket Entry: none.   18-OCT-2016 12:30 AM NOTICE GIVEN     Docket Entry: none.   24-OCT-2016 11:16 AM ENTRY OF APPEARANCE PRATT, MARCEL S   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Entry of Appearance-MSP.pdf   Docket Entry: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF MARCEL S PRATT FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRANK BRESLIN AND CITY OF PHILADELPHIA)   26-OCT-2016 12:30 AM NOTICE GIVEN     Docket Entry: none.   26-OCT-2016 03:50 PM PRAECIPE TO SUPPL/ATTACH FILED ARONCHICK, MARK A   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents 2016-10-26 - Praecipe to Attach Corrected PO Memorandum.pdf   Docket Entry: 40-16100940 PRAECIPE TO SUPPLEMENT/ATTACH RE: PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRANK BRESLIN AND CITY OF PHILADELPHIA)   28-OCT-2016 03:48 PM ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL WILLIAMS CAP, DAVID C   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents EOA DCW.pdf   Docket Entry: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF DAVID C WILLIAMS AS CO-COUNSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PHILADELPHIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, PENNSYLVANIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, DAY'S BEVERAGES, INC., METRO BEVERAGE OF PHILADELPHIA, INC., JOHN'S ROAST PORK, INC., CVP MANAGEMENT, INC., GREGORY J. SMITH, PENNSYLVANIA FOOD MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION AND LORA JEAN WILLIAMS)   31-OCT-2016 05:42 PM ANSWER TO PRELIMINARY OBJCTNS LAVELLE JR., JOHN P   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Answer to POs.pdf Memo in Opposition to POs to Complaint.pdf Proposed Order.pdf EXHIBIT 1.pdf Neely Verification 10.31.16.pdf Certificate of Service.pdf   Docket Entry: 40-16100940 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PHILADELPHIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, PENNSYLVANIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, DAY'S BEVERAGES, INC., METRO BEVERAGE OF PHILADELPHIA, INC., JOHN'S ROAST PORK, INC., CVP MANAGEMENT, INC., GREGORY J. SMITH, PENNSYLVANIA FOOD MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION AND LORA JEAN WILLIAMS)   01-NOV-2016 12:08 PM PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION LAVELLE JR., JOHN P   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Petition for Special Injunction.pdf Memo in Support of Special Injunction.pdf Special Injunction Order.pdf Special Injunction - Rule to Show Cause.pdf EXHIBIT 1.pdf EXHIBIT 2.pdf Certificate of Service.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form   Docket Entry: 27-16110127 PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION (FILED ON BEHALF OF PHILADELPHIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, PENNSYLVANIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, DAY'S BEVERAGES, INC., METRO BEVERAGE OF PHILADELPHIA, INC., JOHN'S ROAST PORK, INC., CVP MANAGEMENT, INC., GREGORY J. SMITH, PENNSYLVANIA FOOD MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION AND LORA JEAN WILLIAMS) ***PLEASE NOTE: THIS FILING WAS SUBMITTED TO THE COURT FOR FILING ON 10/31/16 BUT WAS ERRONEOUSLY REJECTED ON 11/1/16. KBB OJR.   02-NOV-2016 09:36 AM MOTION ASSIGNED     Docket Entry: 27-16110127 PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: GLAZER, GARY S. ON DATE: NOVEMBER 02, 2016   02-NOV-2016 03:20 PM PRELIM OBJECTIONS ASSIGNED     Docket Entry: 40-16100940 PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: GLAZER, GARY S. ON DATE: NOVEMBER 02, 2016   07-NOV-2016 02:51 PM PRAECIPE TO SUPPL/ATTACH FILED SPECTER, SHANIN   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Supp Memo ISO Petition for Special Injunction.pdf   Docket Entry: 27-16110127 PRAECIPE TO SUPPLEMENT/ATTACH RE: PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PHILADELPHIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, PENNSYLVANIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, DAY'S BEVERAGES, INC., METRO BEVERAGE OF PHILADELPHIA, INC., JOHN'S ROAST PORK, INC., CVP MANAGEMENT, INC., GREGORY J. SMITH, PENNSYLVANIA FOOD MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION AND LORA JEAN WILLIAMS)   14-NOV-2016 10:24 PM REPLY-PRELIM. OBJECT. FILED ARONCHICK, MARK A   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents 2016-11-14 - City Reply in Further Support of POs.pdf Exhibit 1 .pdf Exhibit 2.pdf Certificate of Service.pdf   Docket Entry: 40-16100940 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRANK BRESLIN AND CITY OF PHILADELPHIA)   30-NOV-2016 02:35 PM PRAECIPE TO SUPPL/ATTACH FILED ARONCHICK, MARK A   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents 2016-11-30 - Praecipe to Attach.pdf Ex. 1 - Updated and Revised Answer to Plaintiffs Motion for Leave.pdf Ex. 2 - Supporting Memorandum of Law.pdf Ex. 3 - Revised Proposed Order.pdf   Docket Entry: 63-16092063 PRAECIPE TO SUPPLEMENT/ATTACH RE: MISCELLANEOUS MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRANK BRESLIN AND CITY OF PHILADELPHIA)   02-DEC-2016 11:12 AM MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED SPECTER, SHANIN   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents 2016.12.2 Plaintiffs Reply to the Citys Updated and Revised Answer and Supporting MOL in Response to Plaintiffs Motion for Leave to File MOL in Support of Declaratory Injunctive Relief.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form   Docket Entry: 63-16092063 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MISCELLANEOUS MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PHILADELPHIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, PENNSYLVANIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, DAY'S BEVERAGES, INC., METRO BEVERAGE OF PHILADELPHIA, INC., JOHN'S ROAST PORK, INC., CVP MANAGEMENT, INC., GREGORY J. SMITH, PENNSYLVANIA FOOD MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION AND LORA JEAN WILLIAMS)   02-DEC-2016 11:25 AM PRAECIPE TO SUPPL/ATTACH FILED SPECTER, SHANIN   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents 2016.12.2 Plaintiffs 2nd Supp Memo ISO Plaintiffs Petition for Special Injunction.pdf   Docket Entry: 27-16110127 PRAECIPE TO SUPPLEMENT/ATTACH RE: PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PHILADELPHIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, PENNSYLVANIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, DAY'S BEVERAGES, INC., METRO BEVERAGE OF PHILADELPHIA, INC., JOHN'S ROAST PORK, INC., CVP MANAGEMENT, INC., GREGORY J. SMITH, PENNSYLVANIA FOOD MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION AND LORA JEAN WILLIAMS)   05-DEC-2016 04:22 PM MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED TRUJILLO, KENNETH I   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Lora Jean Williams, et al. v. City of Philadelphia, et al. - Defendants Surreply Opposing Plaintiffs 2nd Memo of Law re Petition.pdf Motion CoverSheet Form   Docket Entry: 63-16092063 REPLY IN OPPOSITION OF MISCELLANEOUS MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRANK BRESLIN AND CITY OF PHILADELPHIA)   19-DEC-2016 09:33 AM ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OLESH, MATTHEW S   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Olesh - Entry of Appearance.pdf   Docket Entry: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF MATTHEW S OLESH FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF FRANK BRESLIN AND CITY OF PHILADELPHIA)   19-DEC-2016 11:48 AM ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents ORDER_46.pdf   Docket Entry: 63-16092063 AND NOW, THIS 19TH DAY OF DECEMBER, 2016, UPON CONSIDERATION OF PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF AND DEFENDANTS' RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION, IT HEREBYIS ORDERED THAT THE MOTION IS DENIED AS MOOT. BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 12/19/16.   19-DEC-2016 11:48 AM NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236     Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 19-DEC-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 19-DEC-2016.   19-DEC-2016 11:49 AM ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents ORDER_47.pdf   Docket Entry: 27-16110127 AND NOW, THIS 19TH DAY OF DECEMBER, 2016, UPON CONSIDERATION OF PLAINTIFFS' PETITION FOR SPECIAL INJUNCTION, IT HEREBY IS ORDERED THAT THE MOTION IS DENIED AS MOOT. (SEE FOOTNOTE 1) BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 12/19/16.   19-DEC-2016 11:49 AM NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236     Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 19-DEC-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 19-DEC-2016.   19-DEC-2016 11:51 AM ORDER ENTERED - FINAL DISPOS GLAZER, GARY S   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents ORDRF_48.pdf   Docket Entry: 40-16100940 (ORDER AND OPINION) AND NOW, THIS 19TH DAY OF DECEMBER, 2016, UPON CONSIDERATION OF DEFENDANTS' PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' COMPLAINT, PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION AND DEFENDANTS' REPLY, IT HEREBY IS ORDERED THAT THE PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ARE SUSTAINED AND THE COMPLAINT IS DISMISSED IN ITS ENTIRETY. BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 12/19/16.   19-DEC-2016 11:52 AM NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236     Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 19-DEC-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED - FINAL DISPOS ENTERED ON 19-DEC-2016.   23-DEC-2016 12:29 PM APPEAL TO COMMONWEALTH COURT LAVELLE JR., JOHN P   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Notice of Appeal - Special Injunction.pdf   Docket Entry: ************************************************************** NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM THE DECISION DATED AND DOCKETED ON 12/19/16 BY JUDGE GLAZER, GARY. PROOF OF SERVICE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PHILADELPHIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, PENNSYLVANIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, DAY'S BEVERAGES, INC., METRO BEVERAGE OF PHILADELPHIA, INC., JOHN'S ROAST PORK, INC., CVP MANAGEMENT, INC., GREGORY J. SMITH, PENNSYLVANIA FOOD MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION AND LORA JEAN WILLIAMS)*****************************   23-DEC-2016 12:32 PM APPEAL TO COMMONWEALTH COURT LAVELLE JR., JOHN P   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents Notice of Appeal - Preliminary Objections.pdf   Docket Entry: ************************************************************** NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM THE DECISION DATED AND DOCKETED ON 12/19/16 BY JUDGE GLAZER, GARY. PROOF OF SERVICE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PHILADELPHIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, PENNSYLVANIA BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, AMERICAN BEVERAGE ASSOCIATION, DAY'S BEVERAGES, INC., METRO BEVERAGE OF PHILADELPHIA, INC., JOHN'S ROAST PORK, INC., CVP MANAGEMENT, INC., GREGORY J. SMITH, PENNSYLVANIA FOOD MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION AND LORA JEAN WILLIAMS)******************************   29-DEC-2016 03:15 PM FEE PD PURSUANT TO ORDER     Docket Entry: CHECK NO. 7253 IN THE AMOUNT OF $85.50 DISBURSED TO COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA   29-DEC-2016 03:16 PM FEE PD PURSUANT TO ORDER     Docket Entry: CHECK NO. 7254 IN THE AMOUNT OF $85.50 DISBURSED TO COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA   09-JAN-2017 11:24 AM ORDER OF THE APPELLATE COURT     Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents APGEN_56.pdf   Docket Entry: ORDER OF THE COMMONWEALTH COURT AT 2077 & 2078 CD 2016 THAT UPON REVIEW OF APPELLANTS' UNOPPOSED EMERGENCY APPLICATION TO EXPEDITE CONSOLIDATED APPEALS, THE APPLICATION IS GRANTED AND IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AS FOLLOWS: THE OFFICE OF JUDICIAL RECORDS SHALL TRANSMIT THE ORIGINAL RECORD TO THE COMMONWEALTH COURT WITHIN 14 DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. APPELLANTS SHALL FILE AND SERVE THEIR BRIEF (4 COPIES) AND REPRODUCED RECORD (4 COPIES) BY FEBRUARY 6, 2017. APPELLEES SHALL FILE AND SERVE THEIR BRIEF (4 COPIES) NO LATER THAN MARCH 10, 2014. APPELLANTS' REPLY BRIEF (4 COPIES), IF ANY, SHALL BE FILED AND SERVED NO LATER THAN MARCH 24,2017. ARGUMENT ON APPELLANTS' APPEAL SHALL BE HEARD DURING THE PITTSBURGH, APRIL 3-7, 2017 ARGUMENT COURT AS DIRECTED BY THE CHIEF CLERK. APPELLANT'S APPEAL SHALL BE EXPEDITED FOR DISPOSITION. THE CHIEF CLERK SHALL SEND A COPY OF THIS ORDER TO THE HONORABLE GARY S. GLAZER AND TO ERIC FEDER, JUDICIAL RECORDS OFFICER (CIVIL)   09-JAN-2017 11:24 AM OPINION FILED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S   Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents OPFLD_57.pdf   Docket Entry: OPINION SIGNED ON 1/9/17 BY GLAZER, J.   09-JAN-2017 11:24 AM NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236     Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 09-JAN-2017 OF OPINION FILED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 09-JAN-2017.   09-JAN-2017 01:56 PM APPEAL INVENTORY RECORD SENT     Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents APILM_59.pdf   Docket Entry: PURSUANT TO PA. R.A.P. 1931 (d) APPEAL INVENTORY SENT.   09-JAN-2017 01:56 PM RECORD MAILED/TRANSMITTED     Docket Entry: RECORD SENT TO COMMONWEALTH COURT VIA UPS.   09-JAN-2017 01:56 PM NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236     Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 10-JAN-2017 OF APPEAL INVENTORY RECORD SENT ENTERED ON 09-JAN-2017.   21-MAR-2017 02:48 PM ORDER OF THE APPELLATE COURT     Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents APGEN_62.pdf   Docket Entry: ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT THAT THE APPLICATION FOR EXTRAORDINARY RELIEF AT 2 EM 2017 IS DENIED.....2/13/17.   19-JUN-2017 12:31 PM ORDER AFFIRMED BY APPELLATE CT     Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents APORA_63.pdf   Docket Entry: ORDER OF THE COMMMONWEALTH COURT AT 2077 & 2078 CD 2016 THAT THE ORDER OF THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS IS AFFIRMED......WOJCIK, J. 6/14/17.   19-JUL-2017 12:12 PM PETITION FILED     Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents PETIT_64.pdf   Docket Entry: FOR ALLOWANCE OF APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT AT 321 EAL 2017....7/13/17 (2077 CD 2016)   02-FEB-2018 12:19 PM PERMISSION TO APPEAL GRANTED     Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents APPRG_65.pdf   Docket Entry: TO SUPREME COURT AT 321 & 322 EAL 2017......1/30/18. PER CURIAM.   02-FEB-2018 12:19 PM NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236     Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 02-FEB-2018 OF PERMISSION TO APPEAL GRANTED ENTERED ON 02-FEB-2018.   06-AUG-2018 03:20 PM ORDER AFFIRMED BY APPELLATE CT     Documents: Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents APORA_67.pdf   Docket Entry: ORDER OF THE COMMONWEALTH COURT AFFIRMED BY THE SUPREME COURT OF PA.