No Items in Cart
Civil Docket Report  
A $5 Convenience fee will be added to the transaction at checkout. 
Case Description

 Case ID: 131103197  (Public Case, all documents are free of charge)
 Case Caption: PA STATE UNIVERSITY VS PA MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATIO
 Filing Date: Wednesday, November 27th, 2013
 Court: COMMERCE - EXTRAORDINARY, N/J
 Location: CITY HALL
 Jury: NON JURY
 Case Type:  CONTRACTS OTHER
 Status:  SETTLED AFTER ASSGN TRIAL JUDG

Related Cases

 

120104126 ,  131103195



Case Event Schedule

No case events were found.

Case motions

No case motions were found.

Case Parties

Seq #AssocExpn DateTypeName
1     ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT GAGNE, PAUL G
Address: KLEINBARD LLC
THREE LOGAN
1717 ARCH ST - 5TH FLOOR
PHILADELPHIA PA 19103
(215)568-2000
pgagne@kleinbard.com 		 Aliases: none
 
2 6   PLAINTIFF PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY
Address: 201 OLD MAIN
UNIVERSITY PARK PA 16802 		 Aliases: none
 
3 1   DEFENDANT PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION INSURANCE COMPANY
Address: 380 SENTRY PARKWAY
BLUE BELL PA 19422 		 Aliases: none
 
4     TEAM LEADER GLAZER, GARY S
Address: 469 CITY HALL
PHILADELPHIA PA 19107
(215)686-9540 		 Aliases: none
 
5     DISCOVERY HEARING OFFICER MATHES, STEPHEN J
Address: PO BOX 27784
MARKET SQUARE STATION
PHILADELPHIA PA 19118
(267)335-2493
sjmathes@sjmatheslaw.com 		 Aliases: none
 
6     ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF WOLFE JR., PATRICK J
Address: NARDUCCI, MOORE, FLEISHER
ROEBERG & WOLFE LLP
589 SKIPPACK PIKE, SUITE 300
BLUE BELL PA 19422
(215)628-2550
pjwolfe@bluebelllaw.com 		 Aliases: none
 
7   07-JUL-2016 JUDGE PRO TEMPORE ZUCKER, MARC J
Address: THE WIDENER BLDG., STE. 500
1339 CHESTNUT STREET
PHILADELPHIA PA 19107
(215)241-7792
mzucker@wgpllp.com 		 Aliases: none
 
8     JUDGE PRO TEMPORE MATHES, STEPHEN J
Address: PO BOX 27784
MARKET SQUARE STATION
PHILADELPHIA PA 19118
(267)335-2493
sjmathes@sjmatheslaw.com 		 Aliases: none
 
9     ATTORNEY PRO HAC VICE OSHINSKY, JEROLD
Address: 2029 CENTURY PARK, EAST
SUITE 2000
CENTURY CITY CA 90067 		 Aliases: none
 
10     ATTORNEY PRO HAC VICE KORNFELD, LINDA D
Address: 2029 CENTURY PARK, EAST
SUITE 2000
CENTURY CITY CA 90067 		 Aliases: none


Docket Entries

Filing Date/TimeDocket TypeFiling PartyDisposition Amount
27-NOV-2013
02:18 PM 		ACTIVE CASE    
Docket Entry: none.
 
27-NOV-2013
02:30 PM 		TRANSFER FROM OTHER JURISDICTI GAGNE, PAUL G  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
MHTFJ_2.pdf
  
Docket Entry: PRAECIPE AND CERTIFIED COPY OF RECORD FROM CENTRE COUNTY FILED.
 
10-DEC-2013
02:57 PM 		CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER ISSUED    
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
CMOIS_3.pdf
  
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER, EXTRAORDINARY TRACK NON-JURY - IT IS ORDERED THAT: 1) THE CASE MANAGEMENT AND TIME STANDARDS ADOPTED FOR COMMERCE PROGRAM, STANDARD TRACK CASES SHALL APPLY AND ARE INCORPORATED. 2) ALL DISCOVERY SHALL BE COMPLETED NOT LATER THAN 01-SEP-2014. 3) PLAINTIFF(S) SHALL IDENTIFY AND SUBMIT CURRICULUM VITAE AND EXPERT REPORTS FOR ALL EXPERT WITNESSES INTENDED TO TESTIFY AT TRIAL TO ALL OTHER PARTIES NOT LATER THAN 06-OCT-2014. 4) DEFENDANT(S) AND ANY ADDITIONAL DEFENDANT(S) SHALL INDENTIFY AND SUBMIT CURRICULUM VITAE AND EXPERT REPORTS FOR ALL EXPERT WITNESSES INTENDED TO TESTIFY AT TRIAL TO ALL OTHER PARTIES NOT LATER THAN 03-NOV-2014. 5) ALL PRETRIAL MOTIONS (OTHER THAN MOTIONS IN LIMINE) SHALL BE FILED NOT LATER THAN 17-NOV-2014. 6) A SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE MAY BE SCHEDULED ANY TIME AFTER 02-FEB-2015. 7) A PRETRIAL CONFERENCE MAY BE SCHEDULED ANY TIME AFTER 02-MAR-2015. 9) IT IS EXPECTED THAT THE CASE WILL BE READY FOR TRIAL $9, WHICH IS THE EARLIEST TRIAL DATE PURSUANT TO PA.R.C.P. 212.1 AND COUNSEL SHOULD ANTICIPATE TRIAL TO BEGIN EXPEDITIOUSLY THEREAFTER. ALL COUNSEL ARE UNDER A CONTINUING OBLIGATION AND ARE HEREBY ORDERED TO SERVE A COPY OF THIS ORDER UPON ALL UNREPRESENTED PARTIES AND UPON ALL COUNSEL ENTERING AN APPEARANCE SUBSEQUENT TO THE ENTRY OF THIS ORDER. ... BY THE COURT: GARY GLAZER, J. 10-DEC-2013
 
10-DEC-2013
02:57 PM 		NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236    
Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 11-DEC-2013 OF CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER ISSUED ENTERED ON 10-DEC-2013.
 
10-DEC-2013
03:00 PM 		LISTED-PROJ. SETTLEMENT CONF.    
Docket Entry: none.
 
10-DEC-2013
03:00 PM 		LISTED-PROJ. PRE-TRIAL CONF    
Docket Entry: none.
 
10-DEC-2013
03:01 PM 		LISTED FOR TRIAL    
Docket Entry: none.
 
23-DEC-2013
03:14 PM 		ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED GAGNE, PAUL G  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
PMA Answer to Complaint 003197 (00676737).PDF
  
Docket Entry: ANSWER WITH NEW MATTER TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PA MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION INSURANCE CO)
 
08-JAN-2014
02:31 PM 		ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_9.pdf
  
Docket Entry: 49-13121449 UPON CONSIDERATION OF DFT JOHN DOE A'S MOTION TO BE REMOVED AS A PARTY AND ANY RESPONSE THERETO IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT SAID MOTION IS GRANTED PROVIDED HOWEVER THAT JOHN DOE A SHALL APPEAR AT CLEVELAND OHIO FOR DEPOSITION WITHIN THIRTY (30) DAYS OF THIS ORDER. BY THE COURT....GLAZER J 1/8/14
 
07-APR-2014
04:04 PM 		ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_10.pdf
  
Docket Entry: IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT A STATUS CONFERENCE IS SCHEDULED FOR APRIL 17 2014 AT 9:30AM IN COURTROOM 650 CITY HALL. BY THE COURT...GLAZER J 4/7/14
 
07-APR-2014
04:04 PM 		NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236    
Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-APR-2014 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 07-APR-2014.
 
07-APR-2014
04:05 PM 		LISTED FOR STATUS CONFERENCE    
Docket Entry: none.
 
09-APR-2014
12:31 AM 		NOTICE GIVEN    
Docket Entry: none.
 
09-APR-2014
10:06 AM 		STIPULATION APPROVED GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
STPAP_14.pdf
  
Docket Entry: 66-14040366 STIPULATION AND ORDER GOVERNING THE EXCHANGE OF CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION APPROVED BY THE COURT...GLAZER J 4/8/14
 
17-APR-2014
10:36 AM 		ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_15.pdf
  
Docket Entry: IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT STEPHEN J MATHES ESQ PO BOX 27784 MARKET SQUARE STATION PHILA PA 19118 (267)335-2493 IS APPOINTED AS A DISCOVERY MASTER. THE PARTIES ARE TO SHARE THE COSTS EQUALLY. BY THE COURT...GLAZER J 4/17/13
 
23-JUN-2014
11:10 AM 		ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_16.pdf
  
Docket Entry: UPON RECOMMENDATION FROM THE DISCOVERY MASTRE IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT ALL CASE MANAGEMENT DEADLINES IN THIS ACTION ARE EXTENDED SEVEN (7) MONTHS. A NEW CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER WILL BE ISSUED REFLECTING THE EXTENDED DEADLINES. BY THE COURT...GLAZER J 6/23/14
 
23-JUN-2014
11:12 AM 		REVISED CASE MGMT ORDER ISSUED    
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
RVCMO_17.pdf
  
Docket Entry: REVISED CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER - Be advised that the Case Management Order issued for the above-captioned action has been revised as follows: All discovery shall be completed not later than 06-APR-2015. Plaintiff shall submit expert reports not later than 04-MAY-2015. Defendant shall submit expert reports not later than 01-JUN-2015. All pre-trial motions shall be filed not later than 15-JUN-2015. A settlement conference will be scheduled any time after 08-SEP-2015. A pre-trial conference will be scheduled at any time after 05-OCT-2015. It is expected that this case shall be ready for trial by 02-NOV-2015. All other terms and conditions on the original Case Management Order will remain in full force and effect. ...BY THE COURT: GARY GLAZER, J.
 
23-JUN-2014
11:12 AM 		NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236    
Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 23-JUN-2014 OF REVISED CASE MGMT ORDER ISSUED ENTERED ON 23-JUN-2014.
 
12-JAN-2015
11:53 AM 		ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_19.pdf
  
Docket Entry: 31-14123931 UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE JOINT MOTION FOR EXTRAORDINARY RELIEF IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT THE SAID MOTION IS GRANTED. ALL CASE MANAGEMENT DEADLINES ARE EXTENDED FOUR (4) MONTHS A NEW CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER WILL BE ISSUED. BY THE COURT...GLAZER J 1/12/15
 
12-JAN-2015
11:53 AM 		NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236    
Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 12-JAN-2015 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 12-JAN-2015.
 
12-JAN-2015
11:55 AM 		REVISED CASE MGMT ORDER ISSUED    
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
RVCMO_20.pdf
  
Docket Entry: REVISED CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER - Be advised that the Case Management Order issued for the above-captioned action has been revised as follows: All discovery shall be completed not later than 03-AUG-2015. Plaintiff shall submit expert reports not later than 07-SEP-2015. Defendant shall submit expert reports not later than 05-OCT-2015. All pre-trial motions shall be filed not later than 05-OCT-2015. A settlement conference will be scheduled any time after 04-JAN-2016. A pre-trial conference will be scheduled at any time after 01-FEB-2016. It is expected that this case shall be ready for trial by 07-MAR-2016. All other terms and conditions on the original Case Management Order will remain in full force and effect. ...BY THE COURT: GARY GLAZER, J.
 
30-SEP-2015
10:23 AM 		STIPULATION DENIED GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
STPDN_22.pdf
  
Docket Entry: 00-15093400 AND NOW, THIS 30TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2015, UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE JOINT STIPULATION TO EXTEND PRE-TRIAL MOTION DEADLINES, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT THE STIPULATION IS DENIED. (SEE FOOTNOTE 1.) THE MOST RECENT CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER, DOCKETED JANUARY 12, 2015, REMAINS IN FULL EFFECT. BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 9/30/15.
 
02-OCT-2015
10:04 AM 		ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_23.pdf
  
Docket Entry: 36-15100036 AND NOW, THIS 1ST DAY OF OCTOBER, 2015, UPON CONSIDERATION OF DEFENDANT, THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY, AND PLAINTIFF, PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS' ASSOCIATION INSURANCE COMPANY'S, JOINT MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION OF THE COURT'S SEPTEMBER 30, 2015, ORDER DENYING STIPULATION TO EXTEND MOTION CUTOFF DEADLINE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT SAID MOTION IS GRANTED AND THE CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER WILL BE MODIFIED TO REFLECT THE PARTIES' STIPULATION FROM SEPTEMBER 24, 2015 EXTENDING THE PRE-TRIAL MOTION DEADLINE FROM OCTOBER 5, 2015, TO NOVEMBER 6, 2015, AND TO ADD A RESPONSE DEADLINE OF DECEMBER 8, 2015. NO OTHER DEADLINES FROM THE JANUARY 12, 2015, CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER WILL CHANGE AS A RESULT OF THIS ORDER. BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 10/1/15.
 
29-OCT-2015
11:53 AM 		ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_24.pdf
  
Docket Entry: 85-15100885 AND NOW, THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2015, UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY'S ("PENN STATE") MOTION TO SEAL THREE EXHIBITS TO ITS MOTION TO COMPEL PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS' ASSOCIATION INUSRANCE COMPANY'S ("PMA") PRODUCTION OF CLAIMS NOTES OR PORTION THEREOF AND TESTIMONY, AND ANY RESPONSE THERETO, IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT SAID MOTION IS GRANTED. THE UNIVERSITY MAY FILE EXHIBITS 6, 8 AND 9 UNDER SEAL. BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 10/29/15.
 
06-NOV-2015
03:36 PM 		MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT GAGNE, PAUL G  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
Motion re Bad Faith (00910567).PDF
Exhibits A to H to Motion re Bad Faith (00910517).PDF
Exhibits I to L to Motion re Bad Faith (00910518).PDF
Exhibit M (Part 1 of 2) to Motion re Bad Faith (00910523).PDF
Exhibit M (Part 2 of 2) to Motion re Bad Faith (00910524).PDF
Exhibits N to Q to Motion re Bad Faith (00910575).PDF
Exhibits R to W to Motion re Bad Faith (00910576).PDF
Motion CoverSheet Form
  
Docket Entry: 18-15111018 RESPONSE DATE 12/07/2015. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PA MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION INSURANCE CO)
 
06-NOV-2015
03:56 PM 		MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT GAGNE, PAUL G  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
Motion re Trigger (00910578).PDF
Exhibits A to E to Motion re Trigger (00910553).PDF
Exhibits F to G to Motion re Trigger (00910570).PDF
Motion CoverSheet Form
  
Docket Entry: 31-15111031 RESPONSE DATE 12/09/2015. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PA MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION INSURANCE CO)
 
06-NOV-2015
09:04 PM 		MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT GAGNE, PAUL G  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
Motion re Exclusion (00910579).PDF
Exhibits A to C to Motion re Exclusion (00910555).PDF
Exhibits D to G to Motion re Exclusion (00910556).PDF
Motion CoverSheet Form
  
Docket Entry: 32-15111032 RESPONSE DATE 12/09/2015. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PA MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION INSURANCE CO)
 
04-DEC-2015
03:09 PM 		ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_28.pdf
  
Docket Entry: 68-15111068 AND NOW, THIS 4TH DAY OF DECEMBER, 2015, UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY'S ("PENN STATE") MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL, THE RESPONSE THERETO, AND THE PARTIES' AGREEMENT THAT THE REQUESTED SEALING BY PENN STATE IS SOLELY FOR PURPOSES OF TEMPORARILY MAINTAINING THE CONFIDENTIALITY OF DOCUMENTS FOR THE PRESENT SUMMARY JUDGMENT PROCEEDINGS, HAS NO BEARING OR IMPACT ON THE PARTIES' ABILITY TO ARGUE FOR OR AGAINST THE ULTIMATE ADMISSIBILITY OF THE DOCUMENTS AT ISSUE, AND IS WITH A FULL AND COMPLETE RESERVATION OF THE PARTIES RESPECTIVE RIGHTS REGARDING ADMISSIBILITY ON ANY AND ALL GROUNDS, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT: PENN STATE MAY FILE ITS UNREDACTED MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT, UNREDACTED SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM OF LAW, AND EXHIBIT H THERETO, UNDER SEAL AND PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION INSURANCE COMPANY ("PMA") MAY DO THE SAME WITH ITS RESPONSE. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED AND DECREED, THAT THIS ORDER IS SPECIFICALLY LIMITED TO THE SEALING OF THE REQUESTED INFORMATION SOLELY FOR THE PRESENT PENN STATE SUMMARY JUDGMENT MOTION AND ANY RESPONSE THERETO. THIS ORDER DOES NOT ADDRESS AND EXPRESSLY HAS NO IMPACT ON THE ULTIMATE CONFIDENTIALITY OR ADMISSIBILITY OF THE EVIDENCE ADDRESSED IN PENN STATE'S MOTION TO SEAL, OR WHETHER THAT EVIDENCE SHOULD BE CONFIDENTIAL OR SEALED IN ANY FUTURE PROCEEDINGS, INCLUDING TRIAL. THE INFORMATION BEING SEALED FOR THIS MOTION SHALL BE SEALED FOR THE PURPOSES OF TRIAL ABSENT A NEW ORDER OF THE COURT DETERMINING THAT IT SHALL BE SEALED. THE PARTIES' RIGHTS ARE RESPECTIVELY AND SPECIFICALLY RESERVED TO MAKE ALL ARGUMENTS REGARDING THE ADMISSIBILITY AND/OR CONFIDENTIALTY OF THE SUBJECT EVIDENCE ON ALL GROUNDS AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME, AND PMA'S AGREEMENT TO THIS ORDER IS NOT, AND WILL NOT BE DEEMED, AN ACKNOWLEDGMENT THAT THE MATERIALS BEING SEALED ARE CONFIDENTIAL. BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 12/4/15.
 
09-DEC-2015
03:43 PM 		MOTION RESPONSE DATE UPDATED    
Docket Entry: 18-15111018 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT MOTION RESPONSE DATE UPDATED TO 12/09/2015.
 
11-DEC-2015
10:58 AM 		MOTION ASSIGNED    
Docket Entry: 18-15111018 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: GLAZER, GARY S. ON DATE: DECEMBER 11, 2015
 
11-DEC-2015
10:58 AM 		MOTION ASSIGNED    
Docket Entry: 31-15111031 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: GLAZER, GARY S. ON DATE: DECEMBER 11, 2015
 
11-DEC-2015
10:58 AM 		MOTION ASSIGNED    
Docket Entry: 32-15111032 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: GLAZER, GARY S. ON DATE: DECEMBER 11, 2015
 
05-JAN-2016
11:21 AM 		ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_33.pdf
  
Docket Entry: 18-15111018 , 31-15111031 & 32-15111032 AND NOW, THIS 5TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2016, UPON CONSIDERATION OF THOSE OUTSTANDING MOTIONS TO WHICH NO RESPONSE HAVE BEEN FILED, AND ALL OTHER MATTERS OF RECORD IN THESE THREE CONSOLIDATED ACTIONS, IT IS ORDERED THAT ALL OF THE ABOVE-REFERENCED MOTIONS ARE DISMISSED AS MOOT. BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 1/5/16.
 
05-JAN-2016
11:21 AM 		NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236    
Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 05-JAN-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 05-JAN-2016.
 
05-JAN-2016
11:23 AM 		OTHER EVENT CANCELLED GLAZER, GARY S  
Docket Entry: SEE ORDER OF 1/5/16 UNDER CONTROL NUMBERS 15111018, 15111031 & 15111032
 
05-JAN-2016
11:23 AM 		OTHER EVENT CANCELLED GLAZER, GARY S  
Docket Entry: SEE ORDER OF 1/5/16 UNDER CONTROL NUMBERS 15111018, 15111031 & 15111032
 
11-MAR-2016
02:08 PM 		ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_37.pdf
  
Docket Entry: 17-15111017 AND NOW, THIS 11TH DAY OF MARCH, 2016, UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE MOTION OF DEFENDANT, PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS' ASSOCIATION INSURANCE COMPANY ("PMA"), FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON BAD FAITH, AND ANY RESPONSE THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT THE MOTION IS GRANTED AND THAT PARTIAL JUDGMENT IS ENTERED IN FAVOR OF PMA AND AGAINST PLAINTIFF, THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY ("PSU"), ON COUNT IV OF THE FIRST COMPLAINT OF PLAINTIFF, THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY ("PSU"), NOVEMBER 2013, NO. 03197, AS FOLLOWS: (I) PMA DID NOT ACT IN BAD FAITH BY ATTEMPTING TO SELECT EXPERIENCED DEFENSE COUNSEL TO REPRESENT PSU; (II) PMA DID NOT ACT IN BAD FAITH IN DEFENDING THE CLAIMS OF ALLEGED VICTIMS OF CHILDHOOD SEXUAL ABUSE BY GERALD SANDUSKY PURSUANT TO A RESERVATION OF RIGHTS; (III) PMA DID NOT ACT IN BAD FAITH BY FILING A DECLARATORY JUDGMENT ACTION; (IV) PMA DID NOT ACT IN BAD FAITH REGARDING ITS APPROACH TO THE FINDINGS OF THE FREECH REPORT; AND (V) PMA DID NOT ACT IN BAD FAITH IN ITS CONDUCT OF DISCOVERY IN THE COVERAGE LITIGATION. BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 3/11/16.
 
04-MAY-2016
02:05 PM 		ORDER AND OPINION FILED GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDOP_38.pdf
  
Docket Entry: 33-15111033 , 34-15111034 & 35-15111035 AND NOW, THIS 4TH DAY OF MAY, 2016, UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE CROSS-MOTIONS FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF PENN STATE UNIVERSITY ("PSU") AND PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS' ASSOCIATION INSURANCE COMPANY ("PMA"), THE RESPONSES THERETO, AND ALL OTHER MATTERS OF RECORD, AND IN ACCORD WITH THE OPINION ISSUED SIMULTANEOUSLY, IT IS ORDERED AS FOLLOWS: 1. PMA'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON TRIGGER OF COVERAGE IS GRANTED IN PART AND DENIED IN PART AS FOLLOWS: A) WITH RESPECT TO ANY CLAIMS ASSERTED AGAINST PSU BY AN ALLEGED VICTIM OF SEXUAL ABUSE BY GERALD SANDUSKY, THE PMA POLICY THAT IS TRIGGERED, IF ANY, IS ONLY THE POLICY IN PLACE AT THE TIME THAT THE FIRST INCIDENT OF SEXUAL ABUSE OCCURRED; B) WITH RESPECT TO ANY PMA POLICY YEAR, THE NUMBER OF OCCURRENCES FOR THE SANDUSKY-RELATED CLAIMS IS EQUAL TO THE NUMBER OF VICTIMS WHO WERE FIRST ABUSED THAT YEAR; AND C) WITH RESPECT TO ANY CLAIMS ASSERTED BY VICTIMS WHO ALLEGE THEY WERE FIRST ABUSED DURING THE 2005-2006 POLICY YEAR OR ANY SUBSEQUENT YEAR CONTAINING THE SINGLE PERPETRATOR PROVISION, THERE IS ONLY A SINGLE OCCURRENCE UNDER THE APPLICABLE POLICY, REGARDLESS OF THE NUMBER OF VICTIMS OR THE TIME PERIOD OVER WHICH THE ALLEGED ABUSE TOOK PLACE. 2. PMA'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT CONCERNING THE SEXUAL ABUSE OR MOLESTATION EXCLUSION POLICIES IS GRANTED, AND PSU IS NOT ENTITLED TO ANY COVERAGE FOR THE SANDUSKY-RELATED CLAIMS UNDER THE SEVEN INSURANCE POLICIES ISSUED TO PSU BY PMA COVERING THE PERIOD MARCH 1, 1992 TO MARCH 1, 1999. 3. PSU'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON CERTAIN COVERAGE DEFENSES IS GRANTED IN PART AND DENIED IN PART AS FOLLOWS: A) THE EXPECTED OR INTENDED INJURY EXCLUSION DOES NOT BAR COVERAGE UNDER ANY POLICY ISSUED PRIOR TO MAY, 1998; AND B) THE FAILURE TO DISCLOSE DEFENSE DOES NOT APPLY WITH RESPECT TO ANY POLICY ISSUED PRIOR TO MAY, 1998. BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 5/4/16.
 
03-JUN-2016
06:42 PM 		MOT-CERTFY ORDER INTERLOC APPL WOLFE JR., PATRICK J  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
Motion Amend Final Package.pdf
Motion CoverSheet Form
  
Docket Entry: 03-16060603 MOT-CERTFY ORDER INTERLOC APPL (FILED ON BEHALF OF PA STATE UNIVERSITY)
 
06-JUN-2016
12:02 PM 		MOTION ASSIGNED    
Docket Entry: 03-16060603 MOT-CERTFY ORDER INTERLOC APPL ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: GLAZER, GARY S. ON DATE: JUNE 06, 2016
 
06-JUN-2016
03:32 PM 		MOTION RESPONSE DATE UPDATED    
Docket Entry: 03-16060603 MOT-CERTFY ORDER INTERLOC APPL MOTION RESPONSE DATE UPDATED TO 06/23/2016.
 
07-JUN-2016
08:48 AM 		ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_42.pdf
  
Docket Entry: UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY'S MOTION TO CERTIFY ORDERS FOR INTEROCUTORY APPEAL, IT IS ORDERED THAT PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS' ASSOCIATION INSURANCE CO. MAY FILE ITS RESPONSES TO SAID MOTIONS ON OR BEFORE JUNE 23, 2016. ... BY THE COURT: GLAZER, J. 6/6/2016
 
07-JUN-2016
08:48 AM 		NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236    
Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 07-JUN-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 07-JUN-2016.
 
22-JUN-2016
11:31 AM 		ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED GAGNE, PAUL G  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
Response to Motion to Amend Summary Judgment Order for Appeal (01016535x9E3AD).pdf
Motion CoverSheet Form
  
Docket Entry: 03-16060603 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOT-CERTFY ORDER INTERLOC APPL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PA MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION INSURANCE CO)
 
23-JUN-2016
01:41 PM 		CONFERENCE DATE SET    
Docket Entry: none.
 
23-JUN-2016
01:41 PM 		LISTED-PROJ. SETTLEMENT CONF.    
Docket Entry: none.
 
23-JUN-2016
01:41 PM 		OTHER EVENT CANCELLED    
Docket Entry: none.
 
23-JUN-2016
01:41 PM 		OTHER EVENT CANCELLED    
Docket Entry: none.
 
25-JUN-2016
12:30 AM 		NOTICE GIVEN    
Docket Entry: none.
 
27-JUN-2016
11:17 AM 		MOTION ASSIGNED    
Docket Entry: 03-16060603 MOT-CERTFY ORDER INTERLOC APPL ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: GLAZER, GARY S. ON DATE: JUNE 27, 2016
 
30-JUN-2016
01:04 PM 		ORDER AND OPINION FILED GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDOP_51.pdf
  
Docket Entry: 03-16060603 AND NOW, THIS 30TH DAY OF JUNE, 2016, UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY'S MOTIONS TO CERTIFY ORDER FOR INTERLOCUTORY APPEAL, THE PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS' ASSOCIATION INSURANCE CO.'S RESPONSES, AND ALL OTHER MATTERS OF RECORD, AND IN ACCORD WITH THE OPINION ISSUED SIMULTANEOUSLY, IT IS ORDERED THAT SAID MOTION IS DENIED. BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 6/30/16.
 
30-JUN-2016
01:04 PM 		NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236    
Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 30-JUN-2016 OF ORDER AND OPINION FILED ENTERED ON 30-JUN-2016.
 
30-JUN-2016
02:16 PM 		ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_52.pdf
  
Docket Entry: AND NOW, THIS 30TH DAY OF JUNE, 2016, IT IS ORDERED THAT STEPHEN J. MATHES, ESQUIRE, WHO WAS PREVIOUSLY APPOINTED DISCOVERY MASTER IN THESE CONSOLIDATED ACTIONS, SHALL CONDUCT THE SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE IN THESE MATTERS. BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 6/30/16.
 
08-JUL-2016
03:32 PM 		WAITING TO LIST SETTLMNT CONF    
Docket Entry: none.
 
08-JUL-2016
03:33 PM 		LISTED-PROJ. SETTLEMENT CONF.    
Docket Entry: none.
 
09-JUL-2016
12:30 AM 		NOTICE GIVEN    
Docket Entry: none.
 
12-JUL-2016
12:30 AM 		NOTICE GIVEN    
Docket Entry: none.
 
14-JUL-2016
08:37 AM 		NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236    
Docket Entry: none.
 
14-JUL-2016
11:35 AM 		WAITING TO LIST SETTLMNT CONF MATHES, STEPHEN J  
Docket Entry: none.
 
14-JUL-2016
11:36 AM 		LISTED-PROJ. SETTLEMENT CONF.    
Docket Entry: none.
 
16-JUL-2016
12:30 AM 		NOTICE GIVEN    
Docket Entry: none.
 
19-JUL-2016
11:57 AM 		MOTION IN LIMINE GAGNE, PAUL G  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
Motion in limine re Settlements Evidence (01031604x9E3AD).pdf
Exhibits A through E to PMAs Motion in Limine re Settlements Evidence (01031377x9E3AD).pdf
Motion CoverSheet Form
  
Docket Entry: 83-16072183 MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE EVIDENCE REGARDING SETTLEMENT OF CLAIMS BARRED BY THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS (FILED ON BEHALF OF PA MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION INSURANCE CO)
 
19-JUL-2016
02:28 PM 		MOTION ASSIGNED    
Docket Entry: 83-16072183 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: GLAZER, GARY S. ON DATE: JULY 19, 2016
 
19-JUL-2016
03:53 PM 		MOTION RESPONSE DATE UPDATED    
Docket Entry: 83-16072183 MOTION IN LIMINE MOTION RESPONSE DATE UPDATED TO 08/19/2016.
 
20-JUL-2016
12:01 PM 		ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_64.pdf
  
Docket Entry: AND NOW, THIS 20TH DAY OF JULY, 2016, UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE MOTIONS IN LIMINE FILED BY PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION INSURANCE COMPANY, IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY SHALL FILE RESPONSES TO SAID MOTIONS ON OR BEFORE AUGUST 19, 2016. BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 7/20/16.
 
20-JUL-2016
12:02 PM 		NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236    
Docket Entry: NOTICE GIVEN ON 20-JUL-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 20-JUL-2016.
 
01-AUG-2016
03:54 PM 		MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE WOLFE JR., PATRICK J  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
DAT Pro Hac Vice - Proposed Order.pdf
DAT Pro Hac Vice - Motion with Exs A-D Attached.pdf
DAT Pro Hac Vice - Memo of Law.pdf
DAT Pro Hac Vice - Cert of Service.pdf
Motion CoverSheet Form
  
Docket Entry: 44-16080244 RESPONSE DATE 08/22/2016. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PA STATE UNIVERSITY)
 
09-AUG-2016
11:18 AM 		MOTION RESPONSE DATE UPDATED    
Docket Entry: 83-16072183 MOTION IN LIMINE MOTION RESPONSE DATE UPDATED TO 09/29/2016.
 
24-AUG-2016
09:44 AM 		MOTION ASSIGNED    
Docket Entry: 44-16080244 MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: GLAZER, GARY S. ON DATE: AUGUST 24, 2016
 
25-AUG-2016
10:16 AM 		ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_69.pdf
  
Docket Entry: 44-16080244 AND NOW, THIS 241H DAY OF AUGUST, 2016, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF DAVID A. THOMAS, ESQUIRE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THE MOTION IS GRANTED, AND DAVID A. THOMAS, ESQUIRE, IS HEREBY ADMITTED PRO HAC VICE FOR PURPOSES OF THIS MATTER AFTER OBTAINING THE APPROPRIATE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA BUSINESS PRIVILEGE TAX LICENSE PURSUANT TO 19-2602 OF THE PHILADELPHIA CODE. PRO HAC VICE COUNSEL SHALL PAY ALL CITY BUSINESS AND WAGE TAX AS REQUIRED. ...BY THE COURT: GLAZER, J.
 
22-SEP-2016
04:33 PM 		PRAEC/SETTLE DISCONTINUE END WOLFE JR., PATRICK J  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
3197 Praecipe to SDE.pdf
  
Docket Entry: SETTLED VIA S D & E PRAECIPE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF PA STATE UNIVERSITY)
 
27-SEP-2016
08:37 AM 		SETTLED AFTER ASSGN TRIAL JUDG GLAZER, GARY S  
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
WSATJ_71.pdf
  
Docket Entry: CASE SETTLED. BY THE COURT: JUDGE GLAZER, 9/26/16.
 
04-OCT-2016
12:42 PM 		APPEAL WITHDRAWN/DISCONTINUED    
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
APWDS_73.pdf
  
Docket Entry: PETITION FOR REVIEW FILED AT 95 EDM 2016 WITHDRAWN/DISCONTINUED BY ORDER OF PATRICK J. WOLFE, JR, ESQUIRE......9/23/16.


Case Description Related Cases Event Schedule Case Parties Docket Entries