Case Description

	Case ID:	130700866
	Case Caption:	EBAUGH ETAL VS ETHICON WOMEN'S HEALTH AN
	Filing Date:	Wednesday, July 03rd, 2013
	Court:	MT - MASS TORT
	Location:	CL - 100 PENN SQUARE EAST
	Jury:	J - JURY
	Case Type:	XP - MT - PELVIC MESH
	Status:	SATFD - SATISFACTION FILED

Related Cases

No related cases were found.

Case Event Schedule

No case events were found.

Case Parties

Seq #	Assoc	Expn Date	Type	ID	Name
1			ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF	A25321	BALEFSKY, LEE B
Address:	KLINE & SPECTER 1525 LOCUST ST. 19TH FLOOR PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 (215)772-0420 (215)735-0960 - FAX		Aliases:	none
2	1		PLAINTIFF	@7499615	EBAUGH, ELLA
Address:	215 CONEWAGO CREEK ROAD MANCHESTER PA 17345		Aliases:	none
3	16	03-SEP-2014	DEFENDANT	@7499616	PRODESCO INC
Address:	700 WEST PARK AVENUE PERKASIE PA 18944		Aliases:	none
4	1		PLAINTIFF	@7499617	EBAUGH, MARVIN
Address:	215 CONEWAGO CREEK ROAD MANCHESTER PA 17345		Aliases:	none
5	13		DEFENDANT	@7499618	ETHICON WOMENS HEALTH & UROLOGY DIVISION OF ETHICON INC
Address:	P.O. BOX 151 ROUTE 22 WEST SOMERVILLE NJ 08876		Aliases:	none
6	13		DEFENDANT	@7499619	ETHICON INC
Address:	ROUTE 22 WEST SOMERVILLE NJ 08876		Aliases:	none
7	13		DEFENDANT	@7499620	GYNECARE
Address:	ROUTE 22 WEST SOMERVILLE NJ 08876		Aliases:	none
8	13		DEFENDANT	@7499621	JOHNSON & JOHNSON
Address:	ONE JOHNSON & JOHNSON PLAZA NEW BRUNSWICK NJ 08893		Aliases:	none
9		03-SEP-2014	DEFENDANT	@7499622	SECANT MEDICAL
Address:	700 WEST PARK AVENUE PERKASIE PA 18944		Aliases:	none
10	16	03-SEP-2014	DEFENDANT	@7499623	SECANT MEDICAL INC
Address:	700 WEST PARK AVENUE PERKASIE PA 18944		Aliases:	none
11	16	03-SEP-2014	DEFENDANT	@7499624	SECANT MEDICAL LLC
Address:	700 WEST PARK AVENUE PERKASIE PA 18944		Aliases:	none
12		30-APR-2014	TEAM LEADER	J326	BERNSTEIN, MARK I
Address:	530 CITY HALL PHILADELPHIA PA 19107 (215)686-7335		Aliases:	none
13			ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT	A309232	REEVE, ANDREW P
Address:	FAEGRE DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH ONE LOGAN SQUARE 130 N. 18TH ST, SUITE 2000 PHILADELPHIA PA 19103 (215)988-3337 (215)988-2757 - FAX		Aliases:	none
14	13		ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT	A58162	MURPHY, KENNETH A
Address:	TUCKER LAW GROUP, LLC 1801 MARKET STREET SUITE 2500 PHILADELPHIA PA 19103-6996 (215)875-0609 (215)559-6209 - FAX		Aliases:	none
15			ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT	A90363	MERK, MELISSA A
Address:	KLINE & SPECTER, PC 1525 LOCUST ST. PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 (215)792-5618 (215)402-2357 - FAX		Aliases:	none
16		03-JUN-2015	ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT	A56617	TUCKER JR, JOE H
Address:	THE TUCKER LAW GROUP, LLC TEN PENN CENTER 1801 MARKET STREET, SUITE 2500 PHILADELPHIA PA 19103 (215)875-0609 (215)559-6209 - FAX		Aliases:	none
17		12-JUN-2015	ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT	A308902	WITTS, VENYCKLES A
Address:	MITCHELL SANDLER 1120 20TH STREET, NW SUITE 725 WASHINGTON DC 20036 (202)886-5267		Aliases:	none
18			TEAM LEADER	J357	NEW, ARNOLD L
Address:	606 CITY HALL PHILADELPHIA PA 19107 (215)686-7260		Aliases:	none
19	1		ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF	A94430	BALDWIN, KILA B
Address:	130 N. 18TH STREET SUITE 1600 PHILADELPHIA PA 19103 (215)313-9858		Aliases:	none
20	13		ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT	A205593	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Address:	BARNES & THORNBURG LLP 1717 ARCH STREET. STE 4900 PHILADELPHIA PA 19103-2825 (445)201-8910		Aliases:	none
21			ATTORNEY PRO HAC VICE	@9101503	SUTHERLAND, KARI L
Address:	BUTLER SNOW LLP 1200 JEFFERSON AVE SUITE 205 LAFAYETTE MS 38655		Aliases:	none
22			ATTORNEY PRO HAC VICE	@9135900	CALLSEN, JULIE A
Address:	TUCKER ELLIS LLP 950 MAIN AVE SUITE 1100 CLEVELAND OH 44113		Aliases:	none
23			ATTORNEY PRO HAC VICE	@9141087	COMBS, PHILLIP J
Address:	THOMAS COMBS & SPANN PLLC 300 SUMMERS ST SUITE 1380 CHARLESTON WV 25301		Aliases:	none
24	1		ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF	A82899	GOMEZ, CHRISTOPHER A
Address:	1525 LOCUST STREET 19TH FLOOR PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 (215)772-1000 (215)735-0921 - FAX		Aliases:	none
25			ATTORNEY PRO HAC VICE	@9201692	SCHMID, KIM M
Address:	BOWMAN AND BROOKE LLP 150 S. FIFTH ST SUITE 3000 MINNEAPOLIS MN 55402		Aliases:	none
26	1		ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF	A312098	PALMER, TRACIE L
Address:	1525 LOCUST ST PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 (215)772-1384 (215)735-0937 - FAX		Aliases:	none
27	1		ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF	A321277	ROBERTSON, ELIA
Address:	KLINE & SPECTER 1525 LOCUST STREET PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 (215)772-1363		Aliases:	none
28	13		ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT	A89455	SNELL, NILS B
Address:	BUTLER, SNOW, O'MARA, STEVENS 500 OFFICE CENTER DRIVE SUITE 400 FORT WASHINGTON PA 19034 (267)705-4905 (267)705-4901 - FAX		Aliases:	none
29	1		ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF	A313964	CAVALIERE, MICHAEL A
Address:	KLINE & SPECTER PC 1525 LOCUST STREET 19TH FLOOR PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 (215)772-0535 (215)792-5519 - FAX		Aliases:	none
30			ATTORNEY PRO HAC VICE	@9478243	HIGGINBOTHAM, DANIEL R
Address:	THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, PLCC 300 SUMMERS STREET, SUITE 1380 CHARLESTON WV 25301		Aliases:	none
31			ATTORNEY PRO HAC VICE	@9478279	THORNBURGH, DANIEL J
Address:	AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, PLLC 17 E MAIN ST, SUITE 200 PENSACOLA FL 32502		Aliases:	none
32			ATTORNEY PRO HAC VICE	@9478286	ANDERSON, BENJAMIN H
Address:	ANDERSON LAW OFFICES LLC 17138 LORAIN AVENUE SUITE 211 CLEVELAND OH 44111		Aliases:	none
33			ATTORNEY PRO HAC VICE	@9478305	WALKER, JORDAN N
Address:	BUTLER SNOW LLP 1020 HIGHLAND COLONY PARKWAY RIDGELAND MS 39157		Aliases:	none
34			ATTORNEY PRO HAC VICE	@9481813	GALLAGHER, KATHLEEN
Address:	BECK REDDEN 1221 MCKINNEY ST SUITE 4500 HOUSTON TX 77010		Aliases:	none
35			ATTORNEY PRO HAC VICE	@9486931	WEBB, W CURT
Address:	1221 MCKINNEY ST SUITE 4500 HOUSTON TX 77010		Aliases:	none
36	1		ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF	A81910	BECKER, CHARLES L
Address:	KLINE & SPECTER PC 19TH FLOOR 1525 LOCUST ST PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 (215)772-1394 (215)735-5827 - FAX		Aliases:	none
37	1		ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF	A206908	LAIDACKER, RUXANDRA M
Address:	1525 LOCUST STREET, 19TH FLOOR PHILADELPHIA PA 19102-3719 (215)772-1000 (215)735-5827 - FAX		Aliases:	none
38			JUDGE	J487	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Address:	532A CITY HALL PHILADELPHIA PA 19148		Aliases:	none
39	13		ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT	A87604	HICKOK, DOROTHY ALICIA
Address:	FAEGRE DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH ONE LOGAN SQUARE SUITE 2000 PHILADELPHIA PA 19103 (215)988-3364 (215)988-2757 - FAX		Aliases:	none
40	13		ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT	A200274	CARR, WILLIAM L
Address:	MCOMBER MCOMBER & LUBER, P.C. 50 LAKE CENTER DRIVE SUITE 400 MARLTON NJ 08053 (856)985-9800		Aliases:	none

Docket Entries

Filing Date/Time	Docket Type	Filing Party	Disposition Amount
03-JUL-2013 04:22 PM	ACTIV - ACTIVE CASE
Docket Entry:	E-Filing Number: 1307008008
03-JUL-2013 04:22 PM	CIVIJ - COMMENCEMENT CIVIL ACTION JURY	BALEFSKY, LEE B
Docket Entry:	none.
03-JUL-2013 04:22 PM	CMPLT - COMPLAINT FILED NOTICE GIVEN	BALEFSKY, LEE B
Docket Entry:	COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 1018.1 FILED.
03-JUL-2013 04:22 PM	SSCG8 - SHERIFF'S SURCHARGE 8 DEFTS	BALEFSKY, LEE B
Docket Entry:	none.
03-JUL-2013 04:22 PM	JURYT - JURY TRIAL PERFECTED	BALEFSKY, LEE B
Docket Entry:	12 JURORS REQUESTED.
03-JUL-2013 04:22 PM	CLWCM - WAITING TO LIST CASE MGMT CONF	BALEFSKY, LEE B
Docket Entry:	none.
26-JUL-2013 09:03 AM	CMREI - PRAECIPE TO REINSTATE CMPLT	BALEFSKY, LEE B
Docket Entry:	COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 1018.1 REINSTATED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA CEDERBERG-EBAUGH)
26-AUG-2013 10:50 AM	AFDVT - AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FILED
Docket Entry:	AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT UPON SECANT MEDICAL, LLC, SECANT MEDICAL, INC., SECANT MEDICAL AND PRODESCO, INC. BY SHERIFF SERVICE BUCKS ON 08/14/2013 FILED.
27-AUG-2013 12:33 PM	AFDVT - AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FILED
Docket Entry:	AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT UPON JOHNSON & JOHNSON, GYNECARE, ETHICON, INC. AND ETHICON WOMEN'S HEALTH AND UROLOGY, A DIV. OF ETHICON, INC. BY PERSONAL SERVICE ON 08/12/2013 FILED.
06-SEP-2013 03:12 PM	CLLCM - LISTED FOR CASE MGMT CONF
Docket Entry:	none.
06-SEP-2013 04:13 PM	ENAPP - ENTRY OF APPEARANCE	REEVE, ANDREW P
Docket Entry:	ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF MELISSA A GRAFF, KENNETH A MURPHY AND ANDREW P REEVE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON, GYNECARE, ETHICON, INC. AND ETHICON WOMEN'S HEALTH AND UROLOGY, A DIV. OF ETHICON, INC.)
06-SEP-2013 04:13 PM	JURYT - JURY TRIAL PERFECTED
Docket Entry:	12 JURORS REQUESTED.
09-SEP-2013 03:20 PM	ENAPP - ENTRY OF APPEARANCE	TUCKER JR, JOE H
Docket Entry:	ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF JOE H TUCKER,JR. AND VENYCKLES AMANDA WITTS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF SECANT MEDICAL, LLC, SECANT MEDICAL, INC. AND PRODESCO, INC.)
09-SEP-2013 03:20 PM	JURYT - JURY TRIAL PERFECTED
Docket Entry:	12 JURORS REQUESTED.
10-SEP-2013 12:44 AM	CLNGV - NOTICE GIVEN
Docket Entry:	none.
11-SEP-2013 12:36 AM	CLNGV - NOTICE GIVEN
Docket Entry:	none.
12-SEP-2013 04:13 PM	RMEDC - NOT OF REMOVAL TO US DIST CT	REEVE, ANDREW P
Docket Entry:	NOTICE OF REMOVAL TO THE U.S. (EASTERN) DISTRICT COURT UNDER 13-CV-5292. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON, GYNECARE, ETHICON, INC. AND ETHICON WOMEN'S HEALTH AND UROLOGY, A DIV. OF ETHICON, INC.)
16-OCT-2013 04:27 PM	RCDML - RECORD MAILED/TRANSMITTED
Docket Entry:	RECORDS MAILED TO U.S. DISTRICT COURT. UPS# 1Z 5E3 003 03 1019 3407. P.M.
17-APR-2014 04:38 PM	RMUSC - REMANDED BY US DISTRICT COURT
Docket Entry:	ORDERED THAT THIS CASE IS REMANDED TO THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF PHILADELPHIA ON 4/17/14 UNDER 13-CV-32643 AND 13-CV-5292. RECORDS RECEIVED ON CD. P.M.
30-APR-2014 10:26 AM	CLTMT - TRANSFERRED TO MASS TORT
Docket Entry:	CASE TRANSFERRED TO THE PELVIC MESH MASS TORT PROGRAM
30-APR-2014 10:32 AM	CLWMT - WAITING FOR LISTING MASS TORT
Docket Entry:	none.
09-OCT-2014 10:09 AM	SFCMP - COMPLAINT - SHORT FORM	BALEFSKY, LEE B
Docket Entry:	COMPLAINT - SHORT FORM FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA CEDERBERG-EBAUGH)
12-MAY-2016 03:42 PM	ENAPC - ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF KILA B BALDWIN AS CO-COUNSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA CEDERBERG-EBAUGH)
25-MAY-2016 11:13 AM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. TRIAL - 5/8/17, WITH JURY SELECTION 5/4/17. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 5/24/16
25-MAY-2016 11:13 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 25-MAY-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 25-MAY-2016.
25-MAY-2016 11:14 AM	CLLTR - LISTED FOR TRIAL
Docket Entry:	none.
02-SEP-2016 12:26 PM	ENAPC - ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF MOLLY E FLYNN AS CO-COUNSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON, GYNECARE AND ETHICON, INC.)
07-SEP-2016 10:15 AM	MTPHV - MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE	MURPHY, KENNETH A
Docket Entry:	99-16090799 (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
07-SEP-2016 01:20 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	99-16090799 MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: SEPTEMBER 07, 2016
15-SEP-2016 09:00 AM	STPLR - STIPULATION FILED	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	19-16092119 STIPULATION TO AMEND CAPTION FILED. AWAITING JUDICIAL APPROVAL (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA CEDERBERG-EBAUGH)
15-SEP-2016 09:11 AM	STASN - STIPULATION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	19-16092119 STIPULATION FILED ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: SEPTEMBER 15, 2016
16-SEP-2016 12:37 PM	STPAP - STIPULATION APPROVED	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	19-16092119 IT IS STIPULATED THAT THE CAPTION IS AMENDED AS FOLLOWS: PLTF, SHALL BE NAMED AS ELLA MAE EBAUGH. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 9/16/16
16-SEP-2016 12:37 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 16-SEP-2016 OF STIPULATION APPROVED ENTERED ON 16-SEP-2016.
22-SEP-2016 11:53 AM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	99-16090799 IT IS ORDERED THAT KARI SUTHERLAND ESQ IS ADMITTED PRO HAC VICE FOR PURPOSES OF THIS MATTER AFTER OBTAINING THE APPROPRIATE CITY OF PHILA BUSINESS PRIVILEGE TAX LICENSE PURSUANT TO 19-2602 OF THE PHILA CODE. PRO HAC VICE COUNSEL SHALL PAY ALL CITY BUSINESS AND WAGE TAX AS REQUIRED. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 9/21/16
22-SEP-2016 11:53 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 23-SEP-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 22-SEP-2016.
11-OCT-2016 04:16 PM	MTPHV - MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	47-16101347 RESPONSE DATE 10/24/2016. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
20-OCT-2016 09:24 AM	MTPHV - MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE	MURPHY, KENNETH A
Docket Entry:	37-16102337 (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
20-OCT-2016 11:20 AM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	37-16102337 MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: OCTOBER 20, 2016
21-OCT-2016 01:00 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	37-16102337 IT IS ORDERED THAT JULIE CALLSEN ESQ IS ADMITTED PRO HAC VICE FOR PURPOSES OF THIS MATTER AFTER OBTAINING THE APPROPRIATE CITY OF PHILA BUSINESS PRIVILEGE TAX LICENSE PURSUANT TO 19-2602 OF THE PHILA CODE. PRO HAC VICE COUNSEL SHALL PAY ALL CITY BUSINESS AND WAGE TAX AS REQUIRED. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 10/21/16
21-OCT-2016 01:00 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 21-OCT-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 21-OCT-2016.
26-OCT-2016 01:24 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	47-16101347 MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: OCTOBER 26, 2016
01-NOV-2016 03:44 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	47-16101347 IT IS ORDERED THAT PHILLIP COMBS ESQ IS ADMITTED PRO HAC VICE FOR PURPOSES OF THIS MATTER AFTER OBTAINING THE APPROPRIATE CITY OF PHILA BUSINESS PRIVILEGE TAX LICENSE PURSUANT TO 19-2602 OF THE PHILA CODE. PRO HAC VICE COUNSEL SHALL PAY ALL CITY BUSINESS AND WAGE TAX AS REQUIRED. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 11/1/16
01-NOV-2016 03:44 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 02-NOV-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 01-NOV-2016.
04-NOV-2016 03:02 PM	ENAPC - ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL	GOMEZ, CHRISTOPHER A
Docket Entry:	ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF CHRISTOPHER A GOMEZ AS CO-COUNSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
30-NOV-2016 03:43 PM	MTPHV - MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	55-16120055 (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
01-DEC-2016 02:35 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	55-16120055 MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: DECEMBER 01, 2016
06-DEC-2016 02:51 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	FOX, IDEE C
Docket Entry:	FIRST AMENDED CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER ENTERED. TRIAL SCHEDULED FOR 5/8/17, WITH JURY SELECTION ON 5/4/17. SEE ORDER. BY THE COURT ...FOX,J 12/6/16
06-DEC-2016 02:51 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 07-DEC-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 06-DEC-2016.
21-DEC-2016 09:53 AM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	55-16120055 IT IS ORDERED THAT KIM SCHMID ESQ IS ADMITTED PRO HAC VICE FOR PURPOSES OF THIS MATTER AFTER OBTAINING THE APPROPRIATE CITY OF PHILA BUSINESS PRIVILEGE TAX LICENSE PURSUANT TO 19-2602 OF THE PHILA CODE. PRO HAC VICE COUNSEL SHALL PAY ALL CITY BUSINESS AND WAGE TAX AS REQUIRED. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 12/20/16
21-DEC-2016 09:53 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 21-DEC-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 21-DEC-2016.
03-JAN-2017 03:42 PM	ENAPC - ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF TRACIE L PALMER AS CO-COUNSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
30-JAN-2017 02:17 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	SECOND AMENDED CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER ENTERED. TRIAL SCHEDULED FOR 7/31/17, WITH JURY SELECTION ON 7/27/17. SEE ORDER FOR COMPLETE TERMS. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 1/30/17
30-JAN-2017 02:17 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 30-JAN-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 30-JAN-2017.
30-JAN-2017 02:18 PM	CLRBC - CASE RESCHEDULED BY COURT
Docket Entry:	none.
30-JAN-2017 02:18 PM	CLLTR - LISTED FOR TRIAL
Docket Entry:	none.
19-MAY-2017 02:35 PM	MTFRY - FRYE MOTION	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	69-17052569 FRYE MOTION (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
19-MAY-2017 02:50 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	69-17052569 FRYE MOTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: MAY 19, 2017
19-MAY-2017 03:52 PM	MTFRY - FRYE MOTION	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	89-17052589 FRYE MOTION (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
19-MAY-2017 03:56 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	89-17052589 FRYE MOTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: MAY 19, 2017
19-MAY-2017 05:31 PM	MTFRY - FRYE MOTION	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	12-17052612 FRYE MOTION (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
19-MAY-2017 06:16 PM	MTSJD - MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	19-17052619 RESPONSE DATE 06/19/2017. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
19-MAY-2017 06:24 PM	MTFRY - FRYE MOTION	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	20-17052620 FRYE MOTION (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
19-MAY-2017 07:14 PM	MTFRY - FRYE MOTION	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	27-17052627 FRYE MOTION (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
22-MAY-2017 10:22 AM	PRATT - PRAECIPE TO SUPPL/ATTACH FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	12-17052612 PRAECIPE TO SUPPLEMENT/ATTACH RE: FRYE MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
22-MAY-2017 02:51 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	27-17052627 FRYE MOTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: MAY 22, 2017
22-MAY-2017 03:00 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	12-17052612 FRYE MOTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: MAY 22, 2017
22-MAY-2017 03:00 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	20-17052620 FRYE MOTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: MAY 22, 2017
26-MAY-2017 02:38 PM	MTFRY - FRYE MOTION	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	34-17053434 FRYE MOTION (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
30-MAY-2017 10:53 AM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	34-17053434 FRYE MOTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: MAY 30, 2017
21-JUN-2017 11:00 AM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	19-17052619 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 21, 2017
26-JUN-2017 02:49 PM	ENAPC - ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL	ROBERTSON, ELIA
Docket Entry:	ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF ELIA ROBERTSON AS CO-COUNSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
26-JUN-2017 03:49 PM	DEPDN - DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
26-JUN-2017 04:40 PM	DEPDN - DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
26-JUN-2017 05:28 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	34-17053434 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF FRYE MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
26-JUN-2017 06:11 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	ROBERTSON, ELIA
Docket Entry:	19-17052619 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
26-JUN-2017 07:02 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	69-17052569 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF FRYE MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
26-JUN-2017 07:12 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	20-17052620 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF FRYE MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
26-JUN-2017 07:16 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	27-17052627 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF FRYE MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
26-JUN-2017 07:20 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	89-17052589 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF FRYE MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
26-JUN-2017 07:21 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	12-17052612 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF FRYE MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
30-JUN-2017 11:26 AM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	18-17063818 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 1 TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT REGARDING THE CHEVRON PHILLIPS MATERIAL SAFETY DATA SHEET (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
30-JUN-2017 11:32 AM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	20-17063820 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 2 TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT REGARDING THE JOHNSON & JOHNSON CREDO (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
30-JUN-2017 12:21 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	30-17063830 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 3 TO EXCLUDE WITNESS STATEMENTS WHICH ESPOUSE SAFETY PRINCIPLES HIGHER THAN THE LAW REQUIRES (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
30-JUN-2017 12:30 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	36-17063836 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 1 TO PRECLUDE ALL REFERENCES TO THE FDA 510(K) CLEARANCE, ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS, AND FDA ADVISORY COMMITTEE STATEMENTS (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
30-JUN-2017 12:36 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	37-17063837 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 2 TO PRECLUDE CERTAIN COMMENTS BY DEFENSE COUNSEL (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
30-JUN-2017 12:39 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	38-17063838 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 3 TO PRECLUDE IRRELEVANT MEDICAL HISTORY (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
30-JUN-2017 12:42 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	39-17063839 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 4 TO PRECLUDE IRRELEVANT PERSONAL HISTORY (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
30-JUN-2017 12:44 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	40-17063840 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 5 TO PRECLUDE REFERENCE TO UNSAVED URODYNAMIC DATA (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
30-JUN-2017 01:42 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	67-17063867 MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE ARGUMENT THAT DEFENDANTS HAD A DUTY TO TRAIN PHYSICIANS (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
30-JUN-2017 01:52 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	68-17063868 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 5 TO EXCLUDE INTERNAL DOCUMENTS THAT ARE IRRELEVANT AND OTHERWISE EXCLUDABLE (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
30-JUN-2017 02:05 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	18-17063818 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 30, 2017
30-JUN-2017 02:10 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	40-17063840 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 30, 2017
30-JUN-2017 02:20 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	74-17063874 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 6 TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT REGARDING FOREIGN EVIDENCE AND REGULATORY ISSUES (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
30-JUN-2017 02:28 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	20-17063820 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 30, 2017
30-JUN-2017 02:28 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	39-17063839 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 30, 2017
30-JUN-2017 02:28 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	30-17063830 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 30, 2017
30-JUN-2017 02:29 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	80-17063880 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 7 TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF PLAINTIFFS' ALLEGATIONS OF SPOLIATION (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
30-JUN-2017 02:44 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	36-17063836 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 30, 2017
30-JUN-2017 02:44 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	38-17063838 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 30, 2017
30-JUN-2017 02:44 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	37-17063837 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 30, 2017
30-JUN-2017 02:50 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	12-17052612 IT IS ORDERED THAT AN EVIDENTIARY HEARING REGARDING DEFTS' MOTION TO EXCLUDE, LIMITED SOLELY TO DR IAKOVLEV'S OPINION THAT THE PRESENCE OF EROSION PROVES THAT A PATIENT HAD AN INFECTION, IS SCHEDULED FOR 7/13/17 AT 10:00 AM IN COURTROOM 602 CITY HALL. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 6/30/17
30-JUN-2017 02:50 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 30-JUN-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 30-JUN-2017.
30-JUN-2017 02:53 PM	RULRT - RULE RETURNABLE SCHEDULED
Docket Entry:	12-17052612 RULE HEARING ON MOTION TO EXCLUDE LISTED FOR 7/13/17 AT 10:00 AM IN COURTROOM 602 CITY HALL.
30-JUN-2017 03:20 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	11-17063911 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 8 TO EXCLUDE DR. MARGOLIS'S OPINIONS BASED UPON HIS OCTOBER 2016 URODYNAMIC TESTING (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
30-JUN-2017 03:21 PM	CORCT - CORRECTIVE ENTRY
Docket Entry:	27-17052627 THE ORDER ENTERED 6/30/17 SCHEDULING ORAL ARGUMENT ON THE MOTION TO EXCLUDE REGARDING DR IAKOVLEV WAS ENTERED UNDER AN INCORRECT CONTROL NUMBER. 17052627 IS THE CORRECT NUMBER. (JNS/COMPLEX LIT CENTER)
30-JUN-2017 03:28 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	14-17063914 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 9 TO EXCLUDE CERTAIN EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENT RELATED TO ETHICON'S DUTY TO WARN (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
30-JUN-2017 03:36 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	67-17063867 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 30, 2017
30-JUN-2017 03:36 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	74-17063874 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 30, 2017
30-JUN-2017 03:36 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	68-17063868 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 30, 2017
30-JUN-2017 03:57 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	80-17063880 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 30, 2017
30-JUN-2017 04:44 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	14-17063914 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 30, 2017
30-JUN-2017 04:44 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	11-17063911 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JUNE 30, 2017
30-JUN-2017 05:14 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	75-17070075 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 11 TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENT REGARDING ULTRAPRO MESH (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
30-JUN-2017 05:21 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	76-17070076 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 12 TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT REGARDING DEFENDANTS'PROFITABILITY, SALES FIGURES, AND ALLEGED IMPROPER PROFIT MOTIVE, AND THE FINANCIAL DISPARITY BETWE (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
30-JUN-2017 05:23 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	78-17070078 MOTION IN LIMINE DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE THAT MS. EBAUGH WAS IMPLANTED WITH A HIP DEVICE MANUFACTURED BY A JOHNSON & JOHNSON COMPANY (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
30-JUN-2017 05:39 PM	MTLIM - MOTION IN LIMINE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	79-17070079 MOTION IN LIMINE (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
03-JUL-2017 10:43 AM	ENAPP - ENTRY OF APPEARANCE	SNELL, NILS B
Docket Entry:	ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF NILS B SNELL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
03-JUL-2017 12:51 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	75-17070075 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JULY 03, 2017
03-JUL-2017 12:51 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	76-17070076 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JULY 03, 2017
03-JUL-2017 12:53 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	78-17070078 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JULY 03, 2017
03-JUL-2017 01:20 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	79-17070079 MOTION IN LIMINE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JULY 03, 2017
03-JUL-2017 03:07 PM	REPLM - MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	34-17053434 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF FRYE MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
03-JUL-2017 03:54 PM	REPLM - MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	20-17052620 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF FRYE MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
03-JUL-2017 04:02 PM	REPLM - MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	12-17052612 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF FRYE MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
03-JUL-2017 04:05 PM	REPLM - MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	27-17052627 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF FRYE MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
03-JUL-2017 04:08 PM	REPLM - MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	69-17052569 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF FRYE MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
03-JUL-2017 04:12 PM	REPLM - MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	89-17052589 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF FRYE MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
03-JUL-2017 04:19 PM	REPLM - MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	19-17052619 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
05-JUL-2017 09:44 AM	MTPHV - MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	71-17070171 (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
05-JUL-2017 11:42 AM	ENAPC - ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL	CAVALIERE, MICHAEL A
Docket Entry:	ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF MICHAEL A. CAVALIERE AS CO-COUNSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
05-JUL-2017 01:01 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	71-17070171 MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JULY 05, 2017
07-JUL-2017 03:39 PM	WITEX - WITNESS/EXHIBIT LIST FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	WITNESS LIST FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
07-JUL-2017 03:41 PM	WITEX - WITNESS/EXHIBIT LIST FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	EXHIBIT LIST FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
11-JUL-2017 11:58 AM	MTPHV - MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	00-17070900 (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
11-JUL-2017 03:06 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	00-17070900 MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JULY 11, 2017
11-JUL-2017 04:08 PM	MTPHV - MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE	BALEFSKY, LEE B
Docket Entry:	67-17070967 UNOPPOSED (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
11-JUL-2017 04:09 PM	MTPHV - MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE	BALEFSKY, LEE B
Docket Entry:	69-17070969 UNOPPOSED (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
12-JUL-2017 01:53 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	69-17070969 MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JULY 12, 2017
12-JUL-2017 01:57 PM	MTPHV - MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	66-17071066 RESPONSE DATE 07/24/2017. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
12-JUL-2017 02:16 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	67-17070967 MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JULY 12, 2017
12-JUL-2017 03:10 PM	DEPDN - DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	OBJECTIONS TO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
12-JUL-2017 04:43 PM	DEPDN - DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	OBJECTIONS TO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
12-JUL-2017 04:45 PM	DEPDN - DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
13-JUL-2017 03:41 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	34-17053434 UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF MICHAEL MARGOLIS, M.D., FILED BY DEFENDANTS ETHICON, INC. AND JOHNSON & JOHNSON, AND ANY RESPONSE THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED SAID MOTION IS DENIED IN PART AND DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE AS FOLLOWS: 1. DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO EXCLUDE DR. MARGOLIS PURSUANT TO PA.R.E. 702 ( C) AND FRYE V. UNITED STATES, 293 F 1013 (D.R. CIR. 1923)(FOLLOWED IN GRADY V. FRITO-LAY, INC., 839 A.2D 1038 (PA 2003) IS DENIED; AND 2. ALL REMAINING ISSUES CONCERNING THE ADMISSIBILITY OF SPECIFIC EVIDENCE ARE DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO BE RAISED BEFORE, AND ADDRESSED BY, THE TRIAL COURT. SEE PA.R.C.P 207.1 (A)(3). ....BY THE COURT: NEW, J. 7/12/17
13-JUL-2017 03:41 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 14-JUL-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 13-JUL-2017.
13-JUL-2017 03:42 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	89-17052589 UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF PEGGY PENCE, PH.D., FILED BY DEFENDANTS ETHICON, INC. AND JOHNSON & JOHNSON, AND ANY RESPONSE THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED SAID MOTION IS DENIED IN PART AND DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE AS FOLLOWS: 1. DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO EXCLUDE DR. PENCE PURSUANT TO PA.R.E. 702 ( C) AND FRYE V. UNITED STATES, 293 F 1013 (D.R. CIR. 1923)(FOLLOWED IN GRADY V. FRITO-LAY, INC., 839 A.2D 1038 (PA 2003) IS DENIED; AND 2. ALL REMAINING ISSUES CONCERNING THE ADMISSIBILITY OF SPECIFIC EVIDENCE ARE DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO BE RAISED BEFORE, AND ADDRESSED BY, THE TRIAL COURT. SEE PA.R.C.P 207.1 (A)(3). ....BY THE COURT: NEW, J. 7/12/17
13-JUL-2017 03:42 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 14-JUL-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 13-JUL-2017.
13-JUL-2017 03:44 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	69-17052569 UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF PROF. DR. MED UWE KLINGE, FILED BY DEFENDANTS ETHICON, INC. AND JOHNSON & JOHNSON, AND ANY RESPONSE THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED SAID MOTION IS DENIED IN PART AND DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE AS FOLLOWS: 1. DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO EXCLUDE PROF. DR. MED. KLINGE PURSUANT TO PA.R.E. 702 ( C) AND FRYE V. UNITED STATES, 293 F 1013 (D.R. CIR. 1923)(FOLLOWED IN GRADY V. FRITO-LAY, INC., 839 A.2D 1038 (PA 2003) IS DENIED; AND 2. ALL REMAINING ISSUES CONCERNING THE ADMISSIBILITY OF SPECIFIC EVIDENCE ARE DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO BE RAISED BEFORE, AND ADDRESSED BY, THE TRIAL COURT. SEE PA.R.C.P 207.1 (A)(3). ....BY THE COURT: NEW, J. 7/12/17
13-JUL-2017 03:44 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 14-JUL-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 13-JUL-2017.
13-JUL-2017 03:48 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	12-17052612 UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF DANIEL ELLIOT, M.D., FILED BY DEFENDANTS ETHICON, INC. AND JOHNSON & JOHNSON, AND ANY RESPONSE THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED SAID MOTION IS DENIED IN PART AND DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE AS FOLLOWS: 1. DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO EXCLUDE DR. ELLIOT PURSUANT TO PA.R.E. 702 ( C) AND FRYE V. UNITED STATES, 293 F 1013 (D.R. CIR. 1923)(FOLLOWED IN GRADY V. FRITO-LAY, INC., 839 A.2D 1038 (PA 2003) IS DENIED; AND 2. ALL REMAINING ISSUES CONCERNING THE ADMISSIBILITY OF SPECIFIC EVIDENCE ARE DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO BE RAISED BEFORE, AND ADDRESSED BY, THE TRIAL COURT. SEE PA.R.C.P 207.1 (A)(3). ....BY THE COURT: NEW, J. 7/12/17
13-JUL-2017 03:48 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 14-JUL-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 13-JUL-2017.
13-JUL-2017 03:49 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	ROBERTSON, ELIA
Docket Entry:	34-17053434 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF FRYE MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
13-JUL-2017 03:50 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	20-17052620 UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF BRUCE ROSENZWEIG, M.D, FILED BY DEFENDANTS ETHICON, INC. AND JOHNSON & JOHNSON, AND ANY RESPONSE THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED SAID MOTION IS DENIED IN PART AND DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE AS FOLLOWS: 1. DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO EXCLUDE DR. ROSENZWEIG PURSUANT TO PA.R.E. 702 ( C) AND FRYE V. UNITED STATES, 293 F 1013 (D.R. CIR. 1923)(FOLLOWED IN GRADY V. FRITO-LAY, INC., 839 A.2D 1038 (PA 2003) IS DENIED; AND 2. ALL REMAINING ISSUES CONCERNING THE ADMISSIBILITY OF SPECIFIC EVIDENCE ARE DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO BE RAISED BEFORE, AND ADDRESSED BY, THE TRIAL COURT. SEE PA.R.C.P 207.1 (A)(3). ....BY THE COURT: NEW, J. 7/12/17
13-JUL-2017 03:50 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 14-JUL-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 13-JUL-2017.
13-JUL-2017 03:54 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	27-17052627 UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF VLADIMIR IAKOVLEV, M.D, FILED BY DEFENDANTS ETHICON, INC. AND JOHNSON & JOHNSON, AND ANY RESPONSE THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED SAID MOTION IS DENIED IN PART AND DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE AS FOLLOWS: 1. IN LIGHT OF PLAINTIFF'S REPRESENTATION THAT DR. IAKOVLEV WILL NOT OFFER THE OPINION THAT THE PRESENCE OF EROSION PROVES PLAINTIFF HAS AN INFECTION, DEFENDANTS MOTION TO EXCLUDE DR. IAKOVLEV PURSUANT TO PA.R.E. 702 ( C) AND FRYE V. UNITED STATES, 293 F 1013 (D.R. CIR. 1923)(FOLLOWED IN GRADY V. FRITO-LAY, INC., 839 A.2D 1038 (PA 2003) IS DENIED; AND 2. ALL REMAINING ISSUES CONCERNING THE ADMISSIBILITY OF SPECIFIC EVIDENCE ARE DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO BE RAISED BEFORE, AND ADDRESSED BY, THE TRIAL COURT. SEE PA.R.C.P 207.1 (A)(3). ....BY THE COURT: NEW, J. 7/12/17
13-JUL-2017 03:54 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 14-JUL-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 13-JUL-2017.
13-JUL-2017 08:17 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	ROBERTSON, ELIA
Docket Entry:	19-17052619 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
14-JUL-2017 10:15 AM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	71-17070171 AND NOW, THIS 13TH DAY OF JULY, 2017, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT THE UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE IS GRANTED, AND DANIEL R. HIGGINBOTHAM OF THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, PLLC, 300 SUMMERS STREET, SUITE 1380, CHARLESTON, WEST VIRGINIA 25301 (WEST VIRGINA BAR LICENSE #11680), IS HEREBY ADMITTED PRO HAC VICE FOR PURPOSES OF THIS MATTER AFTER OBTAINING THE APPROPRIATE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA BUSINESS PRIVILEGE TAX LICENSE PURSUANT TO 19-2602 OF THE PHILADELPHIA CODE. PRO HAC VICE COUNSEL SHALL PAY ALL CITY BUSINESS AND WAGE TAX AS REQUIRED..........BY THE COURT: NEW,J. 7/13/2017
14-JUL-2017 10:15 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 14-JUL-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 14-JUL-2017.
14-JUL-2017 10:23 AM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	67-17070967 AND NOW, THIS 13TH DAY OF JULY, 2017, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT THE UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE IS GRANTED AND DANIEL J. THORNBURGH, ESQ., OF AYLSTOCK, WITKIN, KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, LLC, 17 E. MAIN STREET, SUITE 200, PENSACOLA, FL 32502 IS HEREBY ADMITTED PRO HAC VICE TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS ACTION AFTER OBTAINING THE APPROPRIATE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA BUSINESS PRIVILEGE TAX LICENSE PURSUANT TO 19-2602 OF THE PHILADELPHIA CODE. PRO HAC VICE COUNSEL SHALL PAY ALL CITY BUSINESS AND WAGE TAX AS REQUIRED............BY THE COURT: NEW,J. 7/13/2017
14-JUL-2017 10:23 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 14-JUL-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 14-JUL-2017.
14-JUL-2017 10:38 AM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	69-17070969 AND NOW, THIS 13TH DAY OF JULY, 2017, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT THE UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE IS GRANTED AND BENJAMIN H. ANDERSON, ESQ., OF ANDERSON LAW OFFICES, LLC 17138 LORAIN AVENUE, SUITE 211, CLEVELAND, OH 44111 IS HEREBY ADMITTED PRO HAC VICE TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS ACTION AFTER OBTAINING THE APPROPRIATE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA BUSINESS PRIVILEGE TAX LICENSE PURSUANT TO 19-2602 OF THE PHILADELPHIA CODE. PRO HAC VICE COUNSEL SHALL PAY ALL CITY BUSINESS AND WAGE TAX AS REQUIRED...........BY THE COURT: NEW,J. 7/13/2017
14-JUL-2017 10:38 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 14-JUL-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 14-JUL-2017.
14-JUL-2017 10:44 AM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	00-17070900 AND NOW, THIS 13TH DAY OF JULY, 2017, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT THE UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR ADMISSTION PRO HAC VICE IS GRANTED, AND JORDAN N. WALKER OF BUTLER SNOW LLP AT 1020 HIGHLAND COLONY PARKWAY, RIDGELAND, MISSISSIPPI, 39157 (MS BAR#102483), IS HEREBY ADMITTED PRO HAC VICE FOR PURPOSES OF THIS MATTER AFTER OBTAINING THE APPROPRIATE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA BUSINESS PRIVILEGE TAX LICENSE PURSUANT TO 19-2602 OF THE PHILADELPHIA CODE. PRO HAC VICE COUNSEL SHALL PAY ALL CITY BUSINESS AND WAGE TAX AS REQUIRED..........BY THE COURT: NEW,J. 7/13/2017
14-JUL-2017 10:44 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 14-JUL-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 14-JUL-2017.
17-JUL-2017 03:09 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	ORDER TO DEEM CERTAIN MOTIONS IN LIMINE, RESPONSES THERETO AND RULINGS ISSUED UPON, FILED IN CARLINO V. ETHICON INC, #130603470, AS FILED IN THE ABOVE MATTER IS ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR COMPLETE TERMS. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 7/12/17
17-JUL-2017 03:09 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 19-JUL-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 17-JUL-2017.
18-JUL-2017 02:45 PM	CLOEC - OTHER EVENT CANCELLED
Docket Entry:	67-17070967 ASSIGNMENT EVENT CLOSED. SEE ORDER ENTERED 7/13/17. (JNS/COMPLEX LIT CENTER)
18-JUL-2017 02:45 PM	CLOEC - OTHER EVENT CANCELLED
Docket Entry:	69-17070969 ASSIGNMENT EVENT CLOSED. SEE ORDER ENTERED 7/13/17. (JNS/COMPLEX LIT CENTER)
18-JUL-2017 02:45 PM	CLOEC - OTHER EVENT CANCELLED
Docket Entry:	00-17070900 ASSIGNMENT EVENT CLOSED. SEE ORDER ENTERED 7/13/17. (JNS/COMPLEX LIT CENTER)
18-JUL-2017 02:46 PM	CLOEC - OTHER EVENT CANCELLED
Docket Entry:	71-17070171 ASSIGNMENT EVENT CLOSED. SEE ORDER ENTERED 7/13/17. (JNS/COMPLEX LIT CENTER)
19-JUL-2017 09:37 AM	MTWTD - MOTION/PETITION/STIP WITHDRAWN	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	36-17063836 PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
20-JUL-2017 09:16 AM	DEPDN - DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	79-17070079 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	78-17070078 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	76-17070076 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	75-17070075 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	11-17063911 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	14-17063914 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	80-17063880 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	68-17063868 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	74-17063874 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	67-17063867 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	37-17063837 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	38-17063838 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	30-17063830 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	39-17063839 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	20-17063820 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	40-17063840 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:10 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	18-17063818 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 21-JUL-17
21-JUL-2017 11:16 AM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	19-17052619 IT IS ORDERED DEFTS, ETHICON INC AND JOHNSON & JOHNSON'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT IS GRANTED IN PART AND DENIED IN PART AS FOLLOWS: THE MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT IS GRANTED IN FAVOR OF DEFTS AND AGAINST PLTF ON THE FOLLOWING CLAIMS - COUNT II (STRICT LIABILITY MANUFACTURING DEFECT), COUNT III (STRICT LIABILITY FAILURE TO WARN), COUNT VI (COMMON LAW FRAUD), COUNT VII (FRAUDULENT CONCEALMENT), COUNT VIII (CONSTRUCTIVE FRAUD), COUNT IX (NEGLIGENT MISREPRESENTATION), COUNT X (NEGLIGENT INFLICTION OF EMOTIONAL DISTRESS), COUNT XI (BREACH OF EXPRESS WARRANTY/FAILURE TO CONFORM TO WARRANTY), COUNT XII (BREACH OF IMPLIED WARRANTY), COUNT XIII (VIOLATION OF THE UNFAIR TRADE PRACTICES AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LAW) AND, COUNT XV (UNJUST ENRICHMENT). THE REMAINDER OF THE MOTION IS DENIED. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 7/20/17
21-JUL-2017 11:16 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 24-JUL-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 21-JUL-2017.
21-JUL-2017 11:38 AM	VODIR - PROPOSED VOIR DIRE FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	PROPOSED VOIR DIRE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
21-JUL-2017 11:42 AM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	NEW, ARNOLD L
Docket Entry:	66-17071066 IT IS ORDERED THAT KATHLEEN GALLAGHER ESQ IS ADMITTED PRO HAC VICE FOR PURPOSES OF THIS MATTER AFTER OBTAINING THE APPROPRIATE CITY OF PHILA BUSINESS PRIVILEGE TAX LICENSE PURSUANT TO 19-2602 OF THE PHILA CODE. PRO HAC VICE COUNSEL SHALL PAY ALL CITY BUSINESS AND WAGE TAX AS REQUIRED. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 7/21/17
21-JUL-2017 11:42 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 24-JUL-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 21-JUL-2017.
21-JUL-2017 01:59 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	ROBERTSON, ELIA
Docket Entry:	11-17063911 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 02:15 PM	JRYIN - JURY INSTRUCTIONS	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
21-JUL-2017 02:32 PM	PCFLD - POINTS FOR CHARGE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	POINTS FOR CHARGE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
21-JUL-2017 02:58 PM	REPLM - MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	19-17052619 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
21-JUL-2017 02:59 PM	JRYIN - JURY INSTRUCTIONS	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 03:01 PM	VODIR - PROPOSED VOIR DIRE FILED	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	PROPOSED VOIR DIRE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 03:04 PM	PCFLD - POINTS FOR CHARGE	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	POINTS FOR CHARGE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 03:24 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	ROBERTSON, ELIA
Docket Entry:	67-17063867 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 03:27 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	ROBERTSON, ELIA
Docket Entry:	30-17063830 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 04:10 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	ROBERTSON, ELIA
Docket Entry:	80-17063880 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 04:19 PM	REPLM - MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	37-17063837 REPLY IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
21-JUL-2017 04:22 PM	REPLM - MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	38-17063838 REPLY IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
21-JUL-2017 04:25 PM	REPLM - MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	39-17063839 REPLY IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
21-JUL-2017 04:28 PM	REPLM - MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	40-17063840 REPLY IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
21-JUL-2017 04:35 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	ROBERTSON, ELIA
Docket Entry:	75-17070075 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 05:16 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	ROBERTSON, ELIA
Docket Entry:	68-17063868 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 07:32 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	CAVALIERE, MICHAEL A
Docket Entry:	18-17063818 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 07:34 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	CAVALIERE, MICHAEL A
Docket Entry:	20-17063820 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 07:36 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	CAVALIERE, MICHAEL A
Docket Entry:	14-17063914 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 07:38 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	CAVALIERE, MICHAEL A
Docket Entry:	78-17070078 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 07:40 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	CAVALIERE, MICHAEL A
Docket Entry:	76-17070076 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 07:42 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	CAVALIERE, MICHAEL A
Docket Entry:	79-17070079 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
21-JUL-2017 08:03 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	CAVALIERE, MICHAEL A
Docket Entry:	74-17063874 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
24-JUL-2017 11:02 AM	WITEX - WITNESS/EXHIBIT LIST FILED	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	FIRST AMENDED EXHIBIT LIST FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
24-JUL-2017 03:19 PM	DEPDN - DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
24-JUL-2017 05:14 PM	DEPDN - DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
24-JUL-2017 05:15 PM	DEPDN - DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
25-JUL-2017 01:52 PM	MTPHV - MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	75-17073175 (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
25-JUL-2017 02:25 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	75-17073175 MOT-FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JULY 25, 2017
25-JUL-2017 04:01 PM	MTQSH - MOTION TO QUASH	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	30-17073230 RESPONSE DATE 08/07/2017. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
25-JUL-2017 04:26 PM	MTCMP - MOTION TO COMPEL	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	31-17073231 RESPONSE DATE 08/07/2017. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
25-JUL-2017 07:46 PM	DEPDN - DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	OBJECTIONS TO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
25-JUL-2017 07:51 PM	DEPDN - DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	OBJECTIONS TO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
26-JUL-2017 09:47 AM	PRWDR - PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW IDENTICAL COPY DEPO DESIGNATION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
26-JUL-2017 01:07 PM	DEPDN - DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	OBJECTIONS TO COUNTER DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
26-JUL-2017 05:57 PM	REPLM - MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	80-17063880 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
26-JUL-2017 11:14 PM	DEPDN - DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	OBJECTIONS AND COUNTER DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
27-JUL-2017 12:21 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	ROBERTSON, ELIA
Docket Entry:	67-17063867 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
28-JUL-2017 04:18 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	CAVALIERE, MICHAEL A
Docket Entry:	20-17063820 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
28-JUL-2017 04:40 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	CAVALIERE, MICHAEL A
Docket Entry:	74-17063874 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
30-JUL-2017 05:14 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	79-17070079 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION IN LIMINE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
30-JUL-2017 06:21 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	31-17073231 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION TO COMPEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
31-JUL-2017 12:36 PM	BMFLD - BENCH MEMORANDUM FILED	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	(FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
31-JUL-2017 01:21 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	75-17073175 IT IS ORDERED THAT W. CURT WEBB ESQ IS ADMITTED PRO HAC VICE FOR PURPOSES OF THIS MATTER AFTER OBTAINING THE APPROPRIATE CITY OF PHILA BUSINESS PRIVILEGE TAX LICENSE PURSUANT TO 19-2602 OF THE PHILA CODE. PRO HAC VICE COUNSEL SHALL PAY ALL CITY BUSINESS AND WAGE TAX AS REQUIRED. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 7/31/17
31-JUL-2017 01:21 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 01-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 31-JUL-2017.
02-AUG-2017 08:55 AM	BMFLD - BENCH MEMORANDUM FILED	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO BENCH BRIEF (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
07-AUG-2017 01:58 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	37-17063837 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PARTIES AGREE THAT DEFTS WILL NOT ARGUE THAT MESH LITIGATION IS "LAWYER DRIVEN" OR ARGUE REGARDING THE NATURE AND EXTENT OF LAWYER ADVERTISING. THE PARTIES FURTHER AGREE THAT THEY ARE PERMITTED TO INTRODUCE EVIDENCE REGARDING ANY LAWYER ADVERTISEMENTS THAT PLTF ACTUALLY VIEWED. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
07-AUG-2017 01:58 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 07-AUG-2017.
07-AUG-2017 02:00 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	38-17063838 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PARTIES AGREE THAT DEFTS WILL NOT MAKE ARGUMENT OR PRESENT EVIDENCE REGARDING PLTF'S HERPES DIAGNOSIS. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
07-AUG-2017 02:00 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 07-AUG-2017.
07-AUG-2017 02:23 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	39-17063839 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PARTIES AGREE THAT: THE PARTIES WILL NOT INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT REGARDING THE DEATH OF PLTF, ELLA EBAUGH'S CHILD; PARTIES WILL NOT INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT REGARDING SUICIDE ATTEMPTS; AND DEFTS MAY INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT REGARDING ELLA EBAUGH'S CHILDREN'S ILLNESSES AND THE ARGUMENT WITH MARVIN EBAUGH'S CHILDREN. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT THE REMAINDER OF PLTFS' MOTIION IN LIMINE IS DENIED. DEFTS MAY INTRODUCE EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENT THAT PLTF, ELLA EBAUGH MOVED DIRECTLY FROM HER EX-HUSBAND'S ADDRESS INTO HER CURRENT HUSBAND'S ADDRESS. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
07-AUG-2017 02:23 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 07-AUG-2017.
07-AUG-2017 04:38 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	40-17063840 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PARTIES AGREE THAT DR MARGOLIS MAY TESTIFY ABOUT THE URODYNAMIC TEST THAT HE PERFORMED AND DEFTS MAY CROSS EXAMINE DR MARGOLIS ON THE FACT THAT HE NO LONGER HAS THE TEST RESULTS. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
07-AUG-2017 04:38 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 07-AUG-2017.
07-AUG-2017 04:41 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	18-17063818 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PARTIES AGREE THAT PLTFS WILL NOT INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT ABOUT MATERIAL SAFETY DATA SHEETS. THE PARTIES FURTHER AGREE THAT THEY WILL NOT INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT ABOUT THE CARCINOGENICITY DEGRADATION OR CYTOTOXICITY OF THE MATERIALS OR ABOUT ALLEGED DEFECTS THAT PLTFS CONTEND ARE ASSOCIATED WITH MECHANICALLY CUT MEST. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
07-AUG-2017 04:41 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 07-AUG-2017.
07-AUG-2017 04:46 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	67-17063867 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PARTIES AGREE THAT PLTFS WILL NOT INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT THAT DEFTS HAD A LEGAL DUTY TO TRAIN PHYSICIANS. THE PARTIES FURTHER AGREE THAT THEY MAY INTRODUCE EVIDENCE RELATED TO TRAINING THAT OCCURRED. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
07-AUG-2017 04:46 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 07-AUG-2017.
07-AUG-2017 04:48 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	74-17063874 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PARTIES AGREE THAT PLTFS WILL NOT INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT REGARDING FOREIGN REGULATORY ISSUES INCLUDING THE TGA. THE PARTIES FURTHER AGREE THAT PLTFS MAY INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT REGARDING ACTIONS THAT HAPPENED IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES, THE QUALITY BOARD HOLD AND THE "DEAR DOCTOR" LETTER ISSUES. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
07-AUG-2017 04:48 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 07-AUG-2017.
07-AUG-2017 04:51 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	80-17063880 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PARTIES AGREE THAT PLTFS WILL NOT INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT REGARDING SPOILATION NOR SEEK AN ADVERSE INFERENCE JURY INSTRUCTION. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
07-AUG-2017 04:51 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 07-AUG-2017.
07-AUG-2017 04:53 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	11-17063911 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PARTIES AGREE THAT DR MARGOLIS MAY TESTIFY REGARDING URODYNAMIC DATA AND CYSTOSCOPY, AND DEFTS MAY CROSS-EXAMINE HIM ABOUT SAVING THE DATA. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
07-AUG-2017 04:53 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 07-AUG-2017.
07-AUG-2017 04:57 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	14-17063914 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PARTIES AGREE THAT PLTFS WILL NOT INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT THAT THE IFU WAS DEFECTIVE. THE PARTIES FURTHER AGREE THAT THEY MAY INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT RELATED TO IFUS, RISKS AND WARNINGS IN GENERAL. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
07-AUG-2017 04:57 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 07-AUG-2017.
08-AUG-2017 09:40 AM	BMFLD - BENCH MEMORANDUM FILED	ROBERTSON, ELIA
Docket Entry:	(FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
08-AUG-2017 09:41 AM	BMFLD - BENCH MEMORANDUM FILED	ROBERTSON, ELIA
Docket Entry:	(FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
08-AUG-2017 10:15 AM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	75-17070075 IT IS ORDERED THAT DEFTS' MOTION IN LIMINE IS WITHDRAWN. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
08-AUG-2017 10:15 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 08-AUG-2017.
08-AUG-2017 10:23 AM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	76-17070076 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PARTIES AGREE THAT PLTFS WILL NOT INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT OF A "DAVID AND GOLIATH" ARGUMENT. THE PARTIES FURTHER AGREE THAT PLTFS MAY INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OF DEFTS' SALES FIGURES AND PROFIT MOTIVE. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
08-AUG-2017 10:23 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 08-AUG-2017.
08-AUG-2017 10:25 AM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	30-17063830 IT IS ORDERED THAT DEFTS' MOTION IN LIMINE IS GRANTED IN PART AND DENIED IN PART: PLTFS MAY NOT MAKE ARGUMENT THAT GENERAL SAFETY PRINCIPLES OR INTERNAL COMPANY SAFETY RULES AMOUNT TO A PRINCIPAL OF LAW; AND, DR ROSENZWEIG IS PERMITTED TO TESTIFY AS TO HIS OPINION OF THE GENERAL SAFETY PRINCIPLES AND INTERNAL COMPANY SAFETY RULES AT ISSUE. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
08-AUG-2017 10:25 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 08-AUG-2017.
08-AUG-2017 10:27 AM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	78-17070078 IT IS ORDERED THAT DEFTS' MOTION IN LIMINE IS GRANTED IN PART AND DENIED IN PART: PLTFS MAY NOT INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OR MAKE ARGUMENT REGARDING MS EBAUGH'S PRIOR HIP LITIGATION OR SETTLEMENT OR THAT THE HIP DEVISE WAS MANUFACTURED BY A JOHNSON & JOHNSON CO UNLESS DEFTS "OPEN THE DOOR"; AND, THIS MOTION IS SUBJECT TO REVISITING AS THE CASE UNFOLDS. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
08-AUG-2017 10:27 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 08-AUG-2017.
08-AUG-2017 10:35 AM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	68-17063868 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PARTIES AGREE TO THE FOLLOWING: PLTFS MAY INTRODUCE EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENT REGARDING THE "CASE COW" AND "SHOW ME THE MONEY" DOCUMENTS; AND, PLTFS MAY NOT INTRODUCE EVIDENCE OR ARGUMENT REGARDING THE FEBRUARY 2004 "BRITTLE MESH EMAIL", THE JUNE 2009 "CORRUPT INDUSTRY EMAIL", THE OCTOBER 2002 "ELUSIVE EMAIL", OR THE FEBRUARY 2009 "PERMANENTLY DESTROYED VAGINA EMAIL". IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT THE REMAINDER DEFTS' MOTION IN LIMINE IS GRANTED. THE PARTIES MAY NOT INTRODUCE THE SURGICAL VIDEOS. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 8/7/17
08-AUG-2017 10:35 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-AUG-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 08-AUG-2017.
08-AUG-2017 03:30 PM	PRSUB - PRAECIPE-SUBSTITUTE/ATTACH	PALMER, TRACIE L
Docket Entry:	PRAECIPE TO SUBSTITUTE/ATTACH COURT ORDER TO BENCH BRIEF FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
08-AUG-2017 05:15 PM	BMFLD - BENCH MEMORANDUM FILED	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	(FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
09-AUG-2017 11:34 AM	BMFLD - BENCH MEMORANDUM FILED	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	OPPOSITION TO BENCH MEMORANDUM (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
09-AUG-2017 02:38 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	30-17073230 MOTION TO QUASH ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: AUGUST 09, 2017
09-AUG-2017 02:38 PM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	31-17073231 MOTION TO COMPEL ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: AUGUST 09, 2017
10-AUG-2017 09:03 AM	BMFLD - BENCH MEMORANDUM FILED	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	(FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
10-AUG-2017 12:10 PM	BMFLD - BENCH MEMORANDUM FILED	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO BENCH BRIEF (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
27-AUG-2017 04:37 PM	JRYIN - JURY INSTRUCTIONS	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	AMENDED PROPOSED POINTS FOR CHARGE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
31-AUG-2017 11:39 AM	WITEX - WITNESS/EXHIBIT LIST FILED	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	EXHIBIT LIST FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON, ETHICON, INC. AND ETHICON WOMEN'S HEALTH AND UROLOGY, A DIV. OF ETHICON, INC.)
31-AUG-2017 12:08 PM	MTMIS - MISCELLANEOUS MOTION/PETITION	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	43-17083943 RESPONSE DATE 09/11/2017. DEFENDANTS ETHICON, INC. AND JOHNSON & JOHNSON?S MOTION FOR COMPULSORY NONSUIT (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON, ETHICON, INC. AND ETHICON WOMEN'S HEALTH AND UROLOGY, A DIV. OF ETHICON, INC.)
31-AUG-2017 01:46 PM	JRYIN - JURY INSTRUCTIONS	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
01-SEP-2017 11:07 AM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	43-17083943 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MISCELLANEOUS MOTION/PETITION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
01-SEP-2017 04:01 PM	MTMIS - MISCELLANEOUS MOTION/PETITION	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	28-17090328 RESPONSE DATE 09/11/2017. MOTION FOR DIRECTED VERDICT (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
08-SEP-2017 10:54 AM	ENAPC - ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL	BECKER, CHARLES L
Docket Entry:	ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF CHARLES L BECKER AND RUXANDRA M LAIDACKER AS CO-COUNSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF ELLA EBAUGH)
08-SEP-2017 11:29 AM	WSJVP - JURY VERDICT FOR PLAINTIFF	ERDOS, MICHAEL	$57,100,000.00
Docket Entry:	JURY VERDICT FOR PLTF. $7,100,000.00 IN COMPENSATORY DAMAGES AWARDED. $50,000,000.00 IN PUNITIVE DAMAGES AWARDED. TOTAL DAMAGES AWARDED AGAINST DEFTS: $57,100,000.00. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 9/7/17
08-SEP-2017 11:29 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 12-SEP-2017 OF JURY VERDICT FOR PLAINTIFF ENTERED ON 08-SEP-2017.
12-SEP-2017 12:20 PM	MTDOM - MOTION FOR DELAY DAMAGES	BECKER, CHARLES L
Docket Entry:	01-17091501 RESPONSE DATE 10/03/2017. (FILED ON BEHALF OF ELLA EBAUGH)
15-SEP-2017 02:07 PM	PTTMF - POST TRIAL MOTION	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	04-17092004 POST TRIAL MOTION (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
15-SEP-2017 04:17 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	01-17091501 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF MOTION FOR DELAY DAMAGES FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
18-SEP-2017 01:59 PM	PTTMA - POST TRIAL MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	04-17092004 POST TRIAL MOTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: ERDOS, MICHAEL . ON DATE: SEPTEMBER 18, 2017
27-SEP-2017 01:55 PM	REPLM - MOTION/PETITION REPLY FILED	BECKER, CHARLES L
Docket Entry:	01-17091501 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR DELAY DAMAGES FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
27-SEP-2017 02:10 PM	MTANS - ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED	BECKER, CHARLES L
Docket Entry:	04-17092004 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF POST TRIAL MOTION FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
05-OCT-2017 11:26 AM	MTASN - MOTION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	01-17091501 MOTION FOR DELAY DAMAGES ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: ERDOS, MICHAEL . ON DATE: OCTOBER 05, 2017
07-NOV-2017 02:12 PM	ENAPC - ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL	HICKOK, DOROTHY ALICIA
Docket Entry:	ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF DOROTHY ALICIA HICKOK AS CO-COUNSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
07-NOV-2017 02:16 PM	ENAPC - ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL	CARR, WILLIAM L
Docket Entry:	ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF WILLIAM L CARR AS CO-COUNSEL FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
16-NOV-2017 02:54 PM	WITEX - WITNESS/EXHIBIT LIST FILED	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	EXHIBIT LIST FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
16-NOV-2017 03:35 PM	WITEX - WITNESS/EXHIBIT LIST FILED	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	EXHIBIT LIST FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
18-JAN-2018 11:05 AM	MTWTD - MOTION/PETITION/STIP WITHDRAWN	BECKER, CHARLES L
Docket Entry:	01-17091501 PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW MOTION FOR DELAY DAMAGES FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF ELLA EBAUGH)
18-JAN-2018 11:08 AM	JDVER - JUDGMENT ENTERED ON VERDICT	BECKER, CHARLES L	$57,100,000.00
Docket Entry:	PRAECIPE TO ENTER JUDGMENT ON THE VERDICT IN FAVOR OF ELLA EBAUGH AND AGAINST JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC. IN THE AMOUNT OF $57,100,000.00 FILED. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE PURSUANT TO PARCP 237 FILED. NOTICE UNDER RULE 236. JUDGMENT IS ENTERED.
23-JAN-2018 11:38 AM	STPLR - STIPULATION FILED	FLYNN, MOLLY E
Docket Entry:	07-18012607 STIPULATION TO STIPULATION FOR STAY/SUPERSEDEAS FILED. AWAITING JUDICIAL APPROVAL (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
23-JAN-2018 01:03 PM	STASN - STIPULATION ASSIGNED
Docket Entry:	07-18012607 STIPULATION FILED ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JANUARY 23, 2018
29-JAN-2018 11:45 AM	MMUPD - MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED
Docket Entry:	07-18012607 REASSIGNED TO JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL ON 29-JAN-18
30-JAN-2018 03:05 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	04-17092004 IT IS ORDERED THAT DEFTS, ETHICON INC AND JOHNSON & JOHNSON'S MOTION FOR POST-TRIAL RELIEF IS DENIED AS MOOT. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 1/30/18
30-JAN-2018 03:05 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 31-JAN-2018 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 30-JAN-2018.
01-FEB-2018 11:25 AM	APSUP - APPEAL TO SUPERIOR COURT	HICKOK, DOROTHY ALICIA
Docket Entry:	**************************************************** NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM THE DECISION DATED 9/7/17 AND DOCKETED ON 9/8/17 BY JUDGE ERDOS, MICHAEL. JUDGMENT ENTERED 1/18/18. PROOF OF SERVICE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.) **************************************************
05-FEB-2018 05:01 PM	ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	IT IS ORDERED THAT APPELLANT IS TO FILE OF RECORD IN THIS COURT, AND SERVE ON THE UNDERSIGNED JUDGE, A CONCISE STATEMENT OF THE ERRORS COMPLAINED OF ON APPEAL. THE APPELLANT SHALL FILE AND SERVE THIS STATEMENT NO LATER THAN 21 DAYS FROM ENTRY OF THIS ORDER ON THE DOCKET. APPELLANT IS CAUTIONED THAT ANY ISSUE NOT PROPERLY INCLUDED IN THE STATEMENT TIMELY FILED AND SERVED SHALL BE DEEMED WAIVED. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 2/2/18
05-FEB-2018 05:01 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 07-FEB-2018 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 05-FEB-2018.
09-FEB-2018 12:57 PM	FEEPD - FEE PD PURSUANT TO ORDER
Docket Entry:	CHECK #8169 IN THE AMOUNT OF $90.25 WAS DISBURSED TO SUPERIOR COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
22-FEB-2018 03:57 PM	APSMT - STATEMENT OF MATTERS (1925(B))	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	APPELLANTS' STATEMENT OF MATTERS COMPLAINED OF ON APPEAL PURSUANT TO PA.R.C.P. 1925(B) FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
23-FEB-2018 04:12 PM	PRSUB - PRAECIPE-SUBSTITUTE/ATTACH	MERK, MELISSA A
Docket Entry:	JOINT PRAECIPE TO LODGE DOCUMENTS OF RECORD FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.)
06-MAR-2018 11:23 AM	STPAP - STIPULATION APPROVED	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	07-18012607 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE COURT ADOPTS THE STIPULATION FOR STAY/SUPERSEDEAS IN ITS ENTIRETY. BY THE COURT ...ERDOS,J 3/6/18
06-MAR-2018 11:23 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 08-MAR-2018 OF STIPULATION APPROVED ENTERED ON 06-MAR-2018.
12-JUN-2019 10:31 AM	OPFLD - OPINION FILED/236 NOTICE GIVEN	ERDOS, MICHAEL
Docket Entry:	OPINION SIGNED ON JUNE 12, 2019 BY ERDOS,J.
12-JUN-2019 10:31 AM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 19-JUL-2019 OF OPINION FILED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 12-JUN-2019.
18-JUL-2019 02:46 PM	APILM - APPEAL INVENTORY RECORD SENT
Docket Entry:	PURSUANT TO PA. R.A.P. 1931 (d) APPEAL INVENTORY SENT.
18-JUL-2019 02:46 PM	RCDML - RECORD MAILED/TRANSMITTED
Docket Entry:	RECORD SENT TO SUPERIOR COURT ELECTRONICALLY VIA PACFILE UNDER 463 EDA 2018.
18-JUL-2019 02:46 PM	ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236
Docket Entry:	NOTICE GIVEN ON 19-JUL-2019 OF APPEAL INVENTORY RECORD SENT ENTERED ON 18-JUL-2019.
25-JUL-2019 10:59 AM	SUPPL - SUPPLEMENTAL PLEADING FILED
Docket Entry:	SUPPLEMENTAL PLEADING SENT TO SUPERIOR COURT ELECTRONICALLY VIA PACFILE UNDER 463 EDA 2018.
08-AUG-2019 10:11 AM	SUPPL - SUPPLEMENTAL PLEADING FILED
Docket Entry:	SUPPLEMENTAL PLEADING SENT TO SUPERIOR COURT UNDER 463 EDA 2018. TAB 183 DID NOT MERGE ORIGINALLY AND HAD TO BE SENT AS A SEPERATE PLEADING.
06-JAN-2020 01:51 PM	EXHIB - TRIAL/HEARING EXHIBITS FILED	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	TRIAL/EVIDENTIARY HEARING EXHIBITS/EVIDENCE FILED.
06-JAN-2020 02:25 PM	EXHIB - TRIAL/HEARING EXHIBITS FILED	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	TRIAL/EVIDENTIARY HEARING EXHIBITS/EVIDENCE FILED.
06-JAN-2020 03:55 PM	EXHIB - TRIAL/HEARING EXHIBITS FILED	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	TRIAL/EVIDENTIARY HEARING EXHIBITS/EVIDENCE FILED.
06-JAN-2020 04:29 PM	EXHIB - TRIAL/HEARING EXHIBITS FILED	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	TRIAL/EVIDENTIARY HEARING EXHIBITS/EVIDENCE FILED.
06-JAN-2020 05:11 PM	EXHIB - TRIAL/HEARING EXHIBITS FILED	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	TRIAL/EVIDENTIARY HEARING EXHIBITS/EVIDENCE FILED.
06-JAN-2020 05:47 PM	EXHIB - TRIAL/HEARING EXHIBITS FILED	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	TRIAL/EVIDENTIARY HEARING EXHIBITS/EVIDENCE FILED.
06-JAN-2020 06:58 PM	EXHIB - TRIAL/HEARING EXHIBITS FILED	BALDWIN, KILA B
Docket Entry:	TRIAL/EVIDENTIARY HEARING EXHIBITS/EVIDENCE FILED.
09-JAN-2020 02:36 PM	SUPRS - SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD SENT
Docket Entry:	SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD SENT ELECTRONICALLY UNDER 463 EDA 2018. THIS PLEADING CONSISTED OF THE EXHIBITS FILED ON JAN 6TH 2020.
14-MAY-2020 09:55 PM	PRSUB - PRAECIPE-SUBSTITUTE/ATTACH	BECKER, CHARLES L
Docket Entry:	JOINT PRAECIPE TO LODGE DOCUMENTS OF RECORD FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)
19-NOV-2020 03:16 PM	APWDS - APPEAL WITHDRAWN/DISCONTINUED
Docket Entry:	463 EDA 2018 AND NOW, THIS 16TH DSAY OF NOVEMBER, 2020, THE JOINT APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO DISCONTINUE APPEAL IS GRANTED. PER CURIAM
07-DEC-2020 12:41 PM	SATFD - SATISFACTION FILED	BECKER, CHARLES L
Docket Entry:	ORDER TO SATISFY THE JUDGMENT FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF MARVIN EBAUGH AND ELLA EBAUGH)