| Case ID: | 130700431 | |
| Case Caption: | HUBBARD ETAL VS ETHICON WOMEN'S HEALTH AND UROLOGY | |
| Filing Date: | Tuesday , July 02nd, 2013 | |
| Court: | MT - MASS TORT | |
| Location: | CL - 100 PENN SQUARE EAST | |
| Jury: | J - JURY | |
| Case Type: | XP - MT - PELVIC MESH | |
| Status: | ORDRF - ORDER ENTERED - FINAL DISPOS |
| Seq # | Assoc | Expn Date | Type | ID | Name |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF | A25321 | BALEFSKY, LEE B | ||
| Address: | KLINE & SPECTER
1525 LOCUST ST. 19TH FLOOR PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 (215)772-0420 (215)735-0960 - FAX | Aliases: | none | ||
| 2 | 1 | PLAINTIFF | @7497674 | HUBBARD, DEBORAH | |
| Address: | 13700 NORTH CAVELIER DRIVE
NEW ORLEANS LA 70129 | Aliases: | none | ||
| 3 | 16 | 03-SEP-2014 | DEFENDANT | @7497675 | PRODESCO INC |
| Address: | 700 WEST PARK AVENUE
PERKASIE PA 18944 | Aliases: | none | ||
| 4 | 1 | PLAINTIFF | @7497676 | HUBBARD, DAREN | |
| Address: | 13700 NORTH CAVELIER DRIVE
NEW ORLEANS LA 70129 | Aliases: | none | ||
| 5 | 13 | DEFENDANT | @7497677 | ETHICON WOMEN'S HEALTH AND UROLOGY A DIV OF ETHICON INC | |
| Address: | P. O. BOX 151
ROUTE 22 WEST SOMERVILLE NJ 08876 | Aliases: | none | ||
| 6 | 13 | DEFENDANT | @7497678 | ETHICON INC | |
| Address: | ROUTE 22 WEST
SOMERVILLE NJ 08876 | Aliases: | none | ||
| 7 | 13 | DEFENDANT | @7497679 | GYNECARE | |
| Address: | ROUTE 22 WEST
SOMERVILLE NJ 08876 | Aliases: | none | ||
| 8 | 13 | DEFENDANT | @7497680 | JOHNSON & JOHNSON | |
| Address: | ONE JOHNSON & JOHNSON PLAZA
NEW BRUNSWICK NJ 08893 | Aliases: | none | ||
| 9 | 03-SEP-2014 | DEFENDANT | @7497681 | SECANT MEDICAL | |
| Address: | 700 WEST PARK AVENUE
PERKASIE PA 18944 | Aliases: | none | ||
| 10 | 16 | 03-SEP-2014 | DEFENDANT | @7497682 | SECANT MEDICAL INC |
| Address: | 700 WEST PARK AVENUE
PERKASIE PA 18944 | Aliases: | none | ||
| 11 | 16 | 03-SEP-2014 | DEFENDANT | @7497683 | SECANT MEDICAL LLC |
| Address: | 700 WEST PARK AVENUE
PERKASIE PA 18944 | Aliases: | none | ||
| 12 | 17-APR-2014 | TEAM LEADER | J326 | BERNSTEIN, MARK I | |
| Address: | 530 CITY HALL
PHILADELPHIA PA 19107 (215)686-7335 | Aliases: | none | ||
| 13 | ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT | A309232 | REEVE, ANDREW P | ||
| Address: | FAEGRE DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH
ONE LOGAN SQUARE 130 N. 18TH ST, SUITE 2000 PHILADELPHIA PA 19103 (215)988-3337 (215)988-2757 - FAX | Aliases: | none | ||
| 14 | 13 | ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT | A58162 | MURPHY, KENNETH A | |
| Address: | TUCKER LAW GROUP, LLC
1801 MARKET STREET SUITE 2500 PHILADELPHIA PA 19103-6996 (215)875-0609 (215)559-6209 - FAX | Aliases: | none | ||
| 15 | 13 | ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT | A90363 | MERK, MELISSA A | |
| Address: | KLINE & SPECTER, PC
1525 LOCUST ST. PHILADELPHIA PA 19102 (215)792-5618 (215)402-2357 - FAX | Aliases: | none | ||
| 16 | 03-JUN-2015 | ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT | A56617 | TUCKER JR, JOE H | |
| Address: | THE TUCKER LAW GROUP, LLC
TEN PENN CENTER 1801 MARKET STREET, SUITE 2500 PHILADELPHIA PA 19103 (215)875-0609 (215)559-6209 - FAX | Aliases: | none | ||
| 17 | 16 | 12-JUN-2015 | ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT | A308902 | WITTS, VENYCKLES A |
| Address: | MITCHELL SANDLER
1120 20TH STREET, NW SUITE 725 WASHINGTON DC 20036 (202)886-5267 | Aliases: | none | ||
| 18 | TEAM LEADER | J357 | NEW, ARNOLD L | ||
| Address: | 606 CITY HALL
PHILADELPHIA PA 19107 (215)686-7260 | Aliases: | none | ||
| 19 | ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF | A43872 | TIGER, MICHELLE L | ||
| Address: | YOUMAN & CAPUTO, LLC
3803 WEST CHESTER PIKE SUITE 150 NEWTOWN SQUARE PA 19073 (215)302-1999 (610)808-1772 - FAX | Aliases: | none | ||
| Filing Date/Time | Docket Type | Filing Party | Disposition Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
|
02-JUL-2013
11:30 AM | ACTIV - ACTIVE CASE | ||
| Docket Entry: | E-Filing Number: 1307003809 | ||
|
02-JUL-2013
11:30 AM | CIVIJ - COMMENCEMENT CIVIL ACTION JURY | BALEFSKY, LEE B | |
| Docket Entry: | none. | ||
|
02-JUL-2013
11:30 AM | CMPLT - COMPLAINT FILED NOTICE GIVEN | BALEFSKY, LEE B | |
| Docket Entry: | COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 1018.1 FILED. | ||
|
02-JUL-2013
11:30 AM | SSCG8 - SHERIFF'S SURCHARGE 8 DEFTS | BALEFSKY, LEE B | |
| Docket Entry: | none. | ||
|
02-JUL-2013
11:30 AM | JURYT - JURY TRIAL PERFECTED | BALEFSKY, LEE B | |
| Docket Entry: | 12 JURORS REQUESTED. | ||
|
02-JUL-2013
11:30 AM | CLWCM - WAITING TO LIST CASE MGMT CONF | BALEFSKY, LEE B | |
| Docket Entry: | none. | ||
|
16-AUG-2013
10:36 AM | CMREI - PRAECIPE TO REINSTATE CMPLT | BALEFSKY, LEE B | |
| Docket Entry: | COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 1018.1 REINSTATED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF DAREN HUBBARD AND DEBORAH HUBBARD) | ||
|
29-AUG-2013
04:12 PM | AFDVT - AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FILED | ||
| Docket Entry: | AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT UPON JOHNSON & JOHNSON, GYNECARE, ETHICON, INC. AND ETHICON WOMEN'S HEALTH AND UROLOGY A DIV OF ETHICON INC. BY PERSONAL SERVICE ON 08/20/2013 FILED. | ||
|
06-SEP-2013
10:51 AM | CLLCM - LISTED FOR CASE MGMT CONF | ||
| Docket Entry: | none. | ||
|
06-SEP-2013
03:46 PM | ENAPP - ENTRY OF APPEARANCE | REEVE, ANDREW P | |
| Docket Entry: | ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF MELISSA A GRAFF, KENNETH A MURPHY AND ANDREW P REEVE FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON, GYNECARE, ETHICON, INC. AND ETHICON WOMEN'S HEALTH AND UROLOGY A DIV OF ETHICON INC.) | ||
|
06-SEP-2013
03:46 PM | JURYT - JURY TRIAL PERFECTED | ||
| Docket Entry: | 12 JURORS REQUESTED. | ||
|
09-SEP-2013
03:15 PM | ENAPP - ENTRY OF APPEARANCE | TUCKER JR, JOE H | |
| Docket Entry: | ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF JOE H TUCKER,JR. AND VENYCKLES AMANDA WITTS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF SECANT MEDICAL LLC, SECANT MEDICAL, INC. AND PRODESCO, INC.) | ||
|
09-SEP-2013
03:15 PM | JURYT - JURY TRIAL PERFECTED | ||
| Docket Entry: | 12 JURORS REQUESTED. | ||
|
10-SEP-2013
12:41 AM | CLNGV - NOTICE GIVEN | ||
| Docket Entry: | none. | ||
|
10-SEP-2013
02:36 PM | AFDVT - AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FILED | ||
| Docket Entry: | AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT UPON SECANT MEDICAL LLC, SECANT MEDICAL, INC., SECANT MEDICAL AND PRODESCO, INC. BY SHERIFF SERVICE BUCKS ON 08/26/2013 FILED. | ||
|
11-SEP-2013
12:35 AM | CLNGV - NOTICE GIVEN | ||
| Docket Entry: | none. | ||
|
20-SEP-2013
11:33 AM | RMEDC - NOT OF REMOVAL TO US DIST CT | REEVE, ANDREW P | |
| Docket Entry: | NOTICE OF REMOVAL TO THE U.S. (EASTERN) DISTRICT COURT UNDER 13-CV-5503. (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON, GYNECARE, ETHICON, INC. AND ETHICON WOMEN'S HEALTH AND UROLOGY A DIV OF ETHICON INC.) | ||
|
21-OCT-2013
02:42 PM | RCDML - RECORD MAILED/TRANSMITTED | ||
| Docket Entry: | records mailed to u.s. district court. ups# 1z 5e3 003 03 1019 3603. p.m. | ||
|
23-OCT-2013
12:10 PM | RRECP - RETURN RECEIPT RECEIVED | ||
| Docket Entry: | none. | ||
|
16-APR-2014
10:00 AM | RMUSC - REMANDED BY US DISTRICT COURT | ||
| Docket Entry: | ORDERED THAT THIS CASE IS REMANDED TO THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF PHILADELPHIA ON 4/16/14 UNDER 14-CV-10660 AND 13-CV-05503. RECORDS RECEIVED ON CD. P.M. | ||
|
17-APR-2014
02:09 PM | CLTMT - TRANSFERRED TO MASS TORT | ||
| Docket Entry: | CASE TRANSFERRED TO THE PELVIC MESH MASS TORT PROGRAM | ||
|
17-APR-2014
02:14 PM | CLWMT - WAITING FOR LISTING MASS TORT | ||
| Docket Entry: | none. | ||
|
08-OCT-2014
10:00 AM | SFCMP - COMPLAINT - SHORT FORM | BALEFSKY, LEE B | |
| Docket Entry: | COMPLAINT - SHORT FORM FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF DAREN HUBBARD AND DEBORAH HUBBARD) | ||
|
28-OCT-2014
11:11 AM | PROBJ - PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS | MURPHY, KENNETH A | |
| Docket Entry: | 59-14103259 PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S SHORT FORM COMPLAINT FILED. RESPONSE DATE: 11/17/2014 (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON, INC.) | ||
|
14-NOV-2014
09:19 AM | ANPRO - ANSWER TO PRELIMINARY OBJCTNS | TIGER, MICHELLE L | |
| Docket Entry: | 59-14103259 ANSWER IN OPPOSITION OF PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS FILED. (FILED ON BEHALF OF DAREN HUBBARD AND DEBORAH HUBBARD) | ||
|
18-NOV-2014
02:11 PM | POASN - PRELIM OBJECTIONS ASSIGNED | ||
| Docket Entry: | 59-14103259 PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: NOVEMBER 18, 2014 | ||
|
31-MAR-2015
09:14 AM | CLOEC - OTHER EVENT CANCELLED | ||
| Docket Entry: | 59-14103259 MOTION ASSIGNMENT EVENT CLOSED - SEE ORDER DOCKETED 3/30/15 UNDER MASTER DOCKET #140200829 OVERRULING PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORP, JOHNSON & JOHNSON AND ETHICON INC. | ||
|
09-FEB-2016
12:48 PM | ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN | NEW, ARNOLD L | |
| Docket Entry: | CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER ENTERED. TRIAL - 4/24/17, WITH JURY SELECTION ON 4/20/17. SEE ORDER FOR COMPLETE TERMS. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 2/9/16 | ||
|
09-FEB-2016
12:48 PM | ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236 | ||
| Docket Entry: | NOTICE GIVEN ON 09-FEB-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 09-FEB-2016. | ||
|
09-FEB-2016
12:49 PM | CLLTR - LISTED FOR TRIAL | ||
| Docket Entry: | none. | ||
|
25-MAY-2016
11:10 AM | ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN | FOX, IDEE C | |
| Docket Entry: | FIRST AMENDED CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. TRIAL - 6/5/17, WITH JURY SELECTION 6/1/17. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 5/24/16 | ||
|
25-MAY-2016
11:10 AM | ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236 | ||
| Docket Entry: | NOTICE GIVEN ON 25-MAY-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 25-MAY-2016. | ||
|
25-MAY-2016
11:10 AM | CLRBC - CASE RESCHEDULED BY COURT | ||
| Docket Entry: | none. | ||
|
25-MAY-2016
11:11 AM | CLLTR - LISTED FOR TRIAL | ||
| Docket Entry: | none. | ||
|
15-JUN-2016
02:01 PM | ORDER - ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN | NEW, ARNOLD L | |
| Docket Entry: | SECOND AMENDED CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. TRIAL DATE - 6/5/17, WITH JURY SELECTION ON 6/1/17. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 6/15/16 | ||
|
15-JUN-2016
02:01 PM | ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236 | ||
| Docket Entry: | NOTICE GIVEN ON 15-JUN-2016 OF ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ENTERED ON 15-JUN-2016. | ||
|
09-JAN-2017
03:47 PM | STPLR - STIPULATION FILED | MERK, MELISSA A | |
| Docket Entry: | 17-17010917 STIPULATION TO STIPULATION OF DISMISSAL FILED. AWAITING JUDICIAL APPROVAL (FILED ON BEHALF OF JOHNSON & JOHNSON, GYNECARE, ETHICON, INC. AND ETHICON WOMEN'S HEALTH AND UROLOGY A DIV OF ETHICON INC.) | ||
|
10-JAN-2017
11:25 AM | STASN - STIPULATION ASSIGNED | ||
| Docket Entry: | 17-17010917 STIPULATION FILED ASSIGNED TO JUDGE: NEW, ARNOLD L. ON DATE: JANUARY 10, 2017 | ||
|
10-JAN-2017
04:41 PM | ORDRF - ORDER ENTERED - FINAL DISPOS | NEW, ARNOLD L | |
| Docket Entry: | 17-17010917 IT IS STIPULATED THAT PLTFS VOLUNTARILY DISMISS ANY AND ALL CLAIMS AGAINST DEFTS, WITHOUT COSTS AGAINST ANY PARTY. THIS DISMISSAL SHALL BE WITH PREJUDICE, EXCEPT THAT IT IS FURTHER STIPULATED THAT THE PLTFS MAY RE-FILE THIS MATTER ONLY IN MDL #2327 IN THE US DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF WEST VIRGINIA, WITHIN 30 DAYS OF THE FILING OF THIS STIPULATION, AND IN THAT EVENT ONLY THIS STIPULATED DISMISSAL SHALL NOT BAR THE ASSERTION OF THE CLAIMS IN THAT PROCEEDING. SEE STIPULATION. BY THE COURT ...NEW,J 1/10/17 | ||
|
10-JAN-2017
04:41 PM | ZR236 - NOTICE GIVEN UNDER RULE 236 | ||
| Docket Entry: | NOTICE GIVEN ON 11-JAN-2017 OF ORDER ENTERED - FINAL DISPOS ENTERED ON 10-JAN-2017. | ||