No Items in Cart
Civil Docket Report  
A $5 Convenience fee will be added to the transaction at checkout. 
Case Description

 Case ID: 031100002
 Case Caption: IN RE: BERYLLIUM LITIGATION
 Filing Date: Monday , November 03rd, 2003
 Court: MASS TORT
 Location: 100 PENN SQUARE EAST
 Jury: JURY
 Case Type:  MASS TORT - BERYLLIUM LITIGATI
 Status:  DISPOSED - CASE CLOSED

Related Cases

No related cases were found.


Case Event Schedule

No case events were found.


Case motions

No case motions were found.


Case Parties

Seq #AssocExpn DateTypeName
1     ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF HONIK, RUBEN
Address: 1515 MARKET STREET
SUITE 1100
PHILADELPHIA PA 19102
(215)985-9177
 Aliases: none
 
2 1 18-SEP-2009 ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF MATANOVIC, STEPHAN
Address: MATANOVIC LAW LLC
399 MARKET STREET
SUITE 360
PHILADELPHIA PA 19106
(215)915-7978
 Aliases: none
 
3     ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT ODONNELL, RONDA K
Address: MARSHALL DENNEHEY WARNER
COLEMAN & GOGGIN
2000 MARKET ST., SUITE 2300
PHILADELPHIA PA 19103
(215)575-2697
 Aliases: none


Docket Entries

Filing Date/TimeDocket TypeFiling PartyDisposition AmountApproval/
Entry Date
03-NOV-2003
09:16 AM
ACTIVE CASE     03-NOV-2003
09:17 AM
Docket Entry: none.
 
03-NOV-2003
12:16 PM
TRANSFERRED TO MASS TORT MANFREDI, WILLIAM J   03-NOV-2003
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 94-03092994 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE JOINT MOTION TO COORDINATE CASES AS A MASS TORT IS GRANTED AND THE COORDINATED CASES SHALL BE MANAGED BY THE COMPLEX LITIGATION CENTER. BY THE COURT ...MANFREDI,J 10/31/03
 
02-DEC-2003
02:03 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   02-DEC-2003
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT PURSUANT TO THE DIRECTION OF THE COURT AT THE NOVEMBER 18, 2003 INITIAL CASE MANAGEMENT CONF., ALL DEADLINES APPLICABLE TO CASES WHICH HAVE BEEN TRANSFERRED TO AND WILL BE TRANSFERRED TO THE BERYLLIUM MASS TORT PROGRAM ARE HEREBY STAYED PENDING FURTHER DIRECTION BY THE COURT. BY THE COURT... ACKERMAN,J. 12/1/03
 
12-DEC-2003
11:53 AM
COMPLAINT FILED NOTICE GIVEN     15-DEC-2003
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: MASTER LONG FORM COMPLAINT PURSUANT PA.R.C.P. 1041.2 FILED.
 
29-DEC-2003
09:00 AM
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FILED     02-JAN-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: SERVED DEFT NGK METALS CORP ON 12-18-03 VIA PER/SER FILED.
 
29-DEC-2003
09:00 AM
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FILED     02-JAN-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: SERVED DEFT CABOT CORP ON 12-18-03 VIA PER/SER FILED.
 
31-DEC-2003
11:06 AM
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FILED     05-JAN-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: OF LONG-FORM COMPLAINT BY CERTIFIED MAIL, RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED UPON DFT NGK NORTH AMERICA, INC. ON 12/19/03.
 
13-JAN-2004
09:39 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   13-JAN-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #1 ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...ACKERMAN,J 1/7/04
 
13-JAN-2004
09:40 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   13-JAN-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #2 ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR COMPLETE TERMS. BY THE COURT ...ACKERMAN,J 1/12/04
 
14-JAN-2004
12:33 PM
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FILED     15-JAN-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: SERVED DEFT LEN VELKY ON 12-18-03 VIA DEP/SER, DEFT YASUHITO NIWA ON 12-18-03 VIA DEP/SER, NGH NORTH AMERICA INC.ON 12-18-03 AND DEFT SPOTTS, STEVENS & MCCOY INC. ON 12-22-03 VIA DEP/SER FILED.
 
20-JAN-2004
02:23 PM
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE FILED     22-JAN-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: OF COMPLAINT BY CERTIFIED MAIL, RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED UPON DEFENDANT NGK INDUSTRIES LTD ON 12/17/03 AND BY REGULAR MAIL ON JANUARY 2, 2004 CERTIFIED MAIL RETURNED MARKED "REFUSED" REGULAR MAIL NOT RETURNED WITHIN FIFTEEN (15) DAYS OF MAILING.
 
26-FEB-2004
03:06 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   26-FEB-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #4 ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...ACKERMAN,J 2/24/04
 
26-FEB-2004
03:32 PM
AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED     03-MAR-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: AMENDED MASTER LONG-FORM COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN TWENTY(20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 1018.1 FILED.
 
10-MAR-2004
10:14 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   10-MAR-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #3 ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR COMPLETE TERMS. BY THE COURT ...ACKERMAN,J 3/9/04
 
22-MAR-2004
10:32 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN     22-MAR-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: ORDERED THAT DEFT., NGK INSULATORS, LTD'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ARE OVERRULED ...ACKERMAN, J. 3-17-04
 
26-MAR-2004
01:55 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   26-MAR-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #5 ENTERED (AMENDMENTS TO CMO #1 RELATED TO PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS). SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...ACKERMAN,J 3/26/04
 
26-MAR-2004
01:57 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   26-MAR-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #6 ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...ACKERMAN,J 3/26/04
 
29-MAR-2004
02:25 PM
AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED     30-MAR-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: SECOND AMENDED MASTER LONG FORM COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN TWENTY(20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 1018.1 FILED.
 
05-APR-2004
02:26 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN     05-APR-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: ORDERED TNAT DEFT., INSULATOR'S REQUEST TO AMEND THIS COURT'S ORDER OF 3-17-04 OVERRULING PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO INCLUDE LANGUAGE NECESSARY FOR INSULATORS TO APPEAL THIS COURT'S ORDER IS DENIED...ACKERMAN, J. 4-1-04
 
03-MAY-2004
02:26 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   03-MAY-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #7 ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...ACKERMAN,J 5/3/04
 
04-MAY-2004
02:18 PM
AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED     05-MAY-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: THIRD AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH NOTICE TO DEFEND WITHIN TWENTY(20) DAYS AFTER SERVICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 1018.1 FILED.
 
10-JUN-2004
10:19 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   10-JUN-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: IT IS STIPULATED THAT PLTFS HAVE AN EXTENSION UNTIL 6/16/04 WITHIN WHICH TO FILE ANSWERS AND OPPOSING LETTER BRIEFS TO THE PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS FILED BY DEFTS TO THE THIRD AMENDED MASTER LONG-FORM COMPLAINT AND TO THE AMENDED SHORT-FORM COMPLAINTS. BY THE COURT ...ACKERMAN,J 6/10/04
 
21-JUN-2004
12:41 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   21-JUN-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: IT IS ORDERED THAT PLTFS SHALL HAVE THROUGH 6/23/04 IN WHICH TO FILE RESPONSES AND OPPOSING LETTER BRIEFS TO DEFTS' PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO THE THIRD AMENDED MASTER LONG-FORM COMPLAINT AND TO THE AMENDED SHORT-FORM COMPLAINTS. BY THE COURT ...ACKERMAN,J 6/18/04
 
04-AUG-2004
10:33 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   04-AUG-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: AND NOW, THIS 27TH DAY OF JULY, 2004, PURSUANT TO ORDER FOR ISSUANCE OF RULE RETURNABLE UPON PLAINTIFFS TO SHOW CAUSE WHY JUDGMENTS OF NON PROS SHOULD NOT BE ENTERED ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT, SPOTTS, STEVENS AND MCCOY, INC., DEFENDANT'S PRAECIPES FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT OF NON PROS PURSUANT TO PA R.C.P. 1042.6 AND PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE WHY JUDGMENTS ON NON PROS SHOULD NOT BE ENETRED ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT, SPOTTS, STEVENS AND MCCOY, INC., IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT THE COURT WILL NOT ENTER SUCH JUDGMENTS OF NON PROS. BY THE COURT: ACKERMAN, J. 7-27-04
 
13-AUG-2004
01:17 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN BERNSTEIN, MARK I   13-AUG-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: AND NOW, THIS 13TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2004, UPON CONSIDERATION OF DEFENDANTS, JOINT MASTER PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S THIRD AMENDED MASTER LONG-FORM COMPLAINT AND PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT DEFENDANTS' JOINT PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ARE HEREBY DENIED. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT DEENDANTS SHALL ANSWER PLAINTIFFS' THIRD AMENDED LONG-FORM COMPLAINT WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. BY THE COURT: BERNSTEIN, J. 8-13-04.
 
20-AUG-2004
11:42 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN BERNSTEIN, MARK I   20-AUG-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF DEFENDANT, NGK INSULATORS, LTD., IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT SAID PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ARE HEREBY DENIED. BY THE COURT...BERNSTEIN, J. 8/20/04
 
25-AUG-2004
11:17 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN BERNSTEIN, MARK I   25-AUG-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: UPON CONSIDERATION OF DEFENDANT, SPOTTS, STEVENS & MCCOY'S MASTER PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' THIRD AMENDED MASTER LONG-FORM COMPLAINT AND PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT DEFENDANT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ARE HEREBY DENIED. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT DEFENDANT SHALL ANSWER PLAINTIFFS' THIRD AMENDED LONG-FORM COMPLAINT WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. BY THE COURT...BERNSTEIN, J. 8/25/04
 
31-AUG-2004
11:44 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   31-AUG-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: STIPULATION FOR EXTENSION TO ANSWER AND AMENDMENT TO CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #1 ENTERED. SEE STIPULATION FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...ACKERMAN,J 8/30/04
 
13-SEP-2004
10:11 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   13-SEP-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: IT IS ORDERED THAT PLTFS ARE PROHIBITED FROM OFFERING AT THE TRIAL OF ANY OF THESE CASES EXPERT TESTIMONY THAT ANY LICENSED PROFESSIONAL EMPLOYED BY SPOTTS STEVEN & MCCOY INC DEVIATED FROM AN ACCEPTABLE PROFESSIONAL STANDARD IN CONNECTION WITH THE PERFORMANCE OF WORK AT WHAT THE THIRD AMENDED MASTER LONG COMPLAINT REFERS TO AS "THE READING PLAN". BY THE COURT ...ACKERMAN,J 9/10/04
 
20-SEP-2004
10:41 AM
ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED FULLEM JR, JOSEPH W   22-SEP-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S THIRD AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH NEW MATTER AND NEW MATTER 2252(D) AGAINST DEFENDANTS SPOTTS, STEVENS & MCCOY FILED BY DEFENDANT NGK NORTH AMERICA, INC.
 
20-SEP-2004
02:26 PM
ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED     21-SEP-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT WITH NEW MATTER AND NEW MATTER CROSSCLAIM FILED BY DEFENDANT NGK INSULATORS LTD.'S.
 
20-SEP-2004
04:14 PM
ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED     21-SEP-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: MASTER ANSWER WITH NEW MATTER OF DEFENDANTS NGK METALS CORP YASHUHITO NIWA AND LEN VELKY TO PLAINTIFFS THIRD AMENDED MASTER LONG FORM COMPLAINT
 
21-SEP-2004
02:51 PM
ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED     22-SEP-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: CABOT CORP ANSWER AND NEW MATTER TO PLAINTIFFS' THIRD AMENDED MASTER LONG FORM COMPLAINT
 
01-OCT-2004
11:35 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   01-OCT-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED BY AND BETWEEN THE UNDERSIGNED COUNSEL THAT DEFENDANT CABOT CORPORATION WILL HAVE AN EXTENSION OF TIME UNTIL WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 22, 2004 WITHIN WHICH TO FILE ITS ANSWER TO PLAINTIFFS' THIRD AMENDED MASTER LONG-FORM COMPLAINT. BY THE COURT...ACKERMAN, J. 9/28/04
 
04-OCT-2004
04:42 PM
ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED DELORENZO, THOMAS C   07-OCT-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: FIRST AMENDED MASTER ANSWER WITH NEW MATTER OF DEFENDANTS NGK METALS CORP YASUHITO NIWA AND LEN VELKY TO PLAINTIFFS THIRD AMENDED MASTER LONG FORM COMPLAINT
 
08-OCT-2004
11:18 AM
REPLY FILED FULLEM JR, JOSEPH W   12-OCT-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: ANSWER OF DEFENDANT NGK NORTH AMERICAN INC TO SPORTS STEVENS & MCCOYS NEW MATTER PURSUANT TO PA R C P 2252(D)
 
08-OCT-2004
03:12 PM
PLTF REPLY TO NEW MATTER FILED     12-OCT-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: PLAINTIFFS REPLY TO NEW MATTER OF DEFENDANTS NGK METALS CORP., YASUHITO NIWA AND LEONARD VELKY'S FIRST AMENDED MASTER ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S THIRD AMENDED LONG-FORM COMPLAINT, FILED.
 
08-OCT-2004
03:12 PM
PLTF REPLY TO NEW MATTER FILED     12-OCT-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: PLAINTIFFS REPLY TO NEW MATTER OF DEFENDANT NGK NORTH AMERICA INC.'S ANSWER AND NEW MATTER TO PLAINTIFF'S THIRD AMENDED LONG-FORM COMPLAINT, FILED.
 
08-OCT-2004
03:12 PM
PLTF REPLY TO NEW MATTER FILED     12-OCT-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: PLAINTIFFS REPLY TO NEW MATTER OF DEFENDANT SPOTTS, STEVENS & MCCOY INC.'S ANSWER AND NEW MATTER TO PLAINTIFF'S THIRD AMENDED LONG-FORM COMPLAINT, FILED.
 
08-OCT-2004
03:12 PM
PLTF REPLY TO NEW MATTER FILED     12-OCT-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: PLAINTIFFS REPLY TO NEW MATTER OF DEFENDANT NGK INSULATORS LTD.'S ANSWER AND NEW MATTER TO PLAINTIFF'S THIRD AMENDED LONG-FORM COMPLAINT, FILED.
 
08-OCT-2004
03:12 PM
PLTF REPLY TO NEW MATTER FILED     12-OCT-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: PLAINTIFFS REPLY TO NEW MATTER OF DEFENDANT CABOT CORPORATION'S ANSWER AND NEW MATTER TO PLAINTIFF'S THIRD AMENDED LONG-FORM COMPLAINT, FILED.
 
12-OCT-2004
10:58 AM
REPLY FILED     13-OCT-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: CABOT CORP REPLY TO SPOTTS STEVENS & MCCOY INC'S NEW MATTER PURSUANT TO PA R C P 2252(D)
 
12-OCT-2004
12:50 PM
REPLY FILED DELORENZO, THOMAS C   13-OCT-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: REPLY OF DEFEDANTS NGK METALS CORPORATION YASUHITO NIWA AND LEN VELKY TO NEW MATTER PURSUANT TO PA.R.C.P. 2252(D) OF DEFENDANT SPOTTS, STEVENS, & MCCOY, INC.
 
12-OCT-2004
04:31 PM
ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED     13-OCT-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: FIRST AMENDED ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S THIRD AMENDED MASTER LONG FORM COMPLAINT WITH NEW MATTER AND NEW MATTER 2252(D)AGAINST CO-DEFT SPOTTS STEVENS AND MCCOY INC FILED BY DEFENDANT NGK INSULATORS LTD.
 
13-OCT-2004
04:27 PM
ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED FULLEM JR, JOSEPH W   14-OCT-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: AMENDED ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S 3RD AMENDED MASTER LONG-FORM COMPLAINT WITH NEW MATTER AND NEW MATTER 2252(D) AGAINST SPOTTS, STEVENS & MCCOY FILED BY DEFENDANT NGK NORTH AMERICA INC.
 
27-OCT-2004
02:26 PM
REPLY FILED STROUD, JAMES C   28-OCT-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: ANSWER DEFENDANT NGK INSULATORS, LTD, TO DEFENDANT SPOTTS, STEVENS & MCCOY, INC.'S NEW MATTER PURSUANT TO PA.C.P. 2252(D).
 
29-OCT-2004
04:23 PM
PLTF REPLY TO NEW MATTER FILED     01-NOV-2004
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: PLAINTIFF(S) REPLY TO NEW MATTER OF DEFENDANT(S) NGK INSULATORS, LTD. FIRST AMENDED ANSWER AND NEW MATTER TO PLAINTIFFS' THIRD AMENDED MASTER LONG-FORM COMPLAINT FILED.
 
03-FEB-2005
10:46 AM
MOT TO COMPEL DEPOSITION     07-FEB-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 20-05015320 RESPONSE DATE: 2-14-05 (FILED BY PLTFS)
 
14-FEB-2005
04:18 PM
ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED     15-FEB-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 20-05015320 ANS FILED TO GLOBAL MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY (FILED BY DEFT, NGK NORTH AMERICA)
 
15-FEB-2005
12:03 PM
MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED     15-FEB-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 20-05015320 MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY ASSIGNED TO JUDGE ACKERMAN ON 2-16-05
 
18-FEB-2005
09:34 AM
MOTION/PETITION/STIP WITHDRAWN HONIK, RUBEN   24-FEB-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 20-05015320 MOTION TO COMPEL DEPOSITIONS WITHDRAWN PER LETTER
 
02-MAY-2005
02:39 PM
MOTION TO COMPEL     11-MAY-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 96-05054096 RESPONSE DATE 5-9-05 (FILED BY PLAINTIFFS)
 
05-MAY-2005
03:02 PM
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL     09-MAY-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF DOUGLAS EVANS RESS FILED ON BEHALF OF DFT NGK NORTH AMERICA INC
 
09-MAY-2005
04:11 PM
REPLY FILED     11-MAY-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 96-05054096 REPLY FILED TO ANS TO MOTION TO COMPEL (FILED BY PLAINTIFF)
 
11-MAY-2005
04:08 PM
ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED     11-MAY-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 96-05054096 ANS FILED TO MOTION TO COMPEL (FILED BY NGK INSULATORS)
 
11-MAY-2005
04:14 PM
MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED     11-MAY-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 96-05054096 MOTION TO COMPEL ASSIGNED TO JUDGE ACKERMAN ON 5-11-05
 
11-MAY-2005
04:15 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   11-MAY-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: IT IS ORDERED THAT A RULE RETURNABLE IS ENTERED TO SHOW CAUSE WHY PLAINITFF'S MOTION TO STRIKE DEFENDANT'S OBJECTIONS AND TO PROVIDE MORE SPECIFIC ANSWERS (INCORRECTLY TITLED AS A MOTION TO COMPEL DEFENDANT NGK INSULATORS LTD. TO PRODUCE ELECTRONIC DOCUMENTS) SHOULD NOT BE GRANTED. RULE RETURNABLE THE 13TH DAYS OF MAY, 2005 AT 10:00 A.M. IN COURTROOM 696, CITY HALL, PHILADELPHIA, PA. ...BY THE COURT; ACKERMAN, J. 5-11-05
 
16-MAY-2005
10:18 AM
MOTION TO COMPEL     17-MAY-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 43-05054643 RESPONSE DATE: 5-23-05 (FILED BY PLTFS)
 
16-MAY-2005
03:53 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   16-MAY-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 96 05054096 AND NOW, THIS 16TH DAY OF MAY, 2005, UPON CONSIDERATION OF PLAINTIFFS' MOTION TO COMPEL DEFENDANT, NGK INSULATORS, LTD., TO PRODUCE ELECTRONIC DOCUMENTS RESPONSIVE TO PLAINTIFFS' FIRST SET OF COMBINED INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION, AND DEFENDANT'S RESPONSE, THERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT THE WITHIN MOTION IS MARKED "DISPOSED OF" IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE STENOGRAPHIC RECORD THAT IS BEING MADE TODATE. THIS ORDER IS WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO MOVANT TO SEEK ADDITIONAL RELIEF UPON APPLICATION TO THIS COURT....BY THE COURT: JUDGE NORMAN ACKERMAN
 
19-MAY-2005
11:15 AM
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE-CO COUNSEL RAUCH, LYNN R   20-MAY-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF LYNN R. RAUCH FILED ON BEHALF OF DFT CABOT CORPORATION.
 
20-MAY-2005
11:06 AM
ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED     24-MAY-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 43-05054643 ANS FILED TO MOTION TO COMPEL (FILED BY DEFT, NGK NORTH AMERICA)
 
23-MAY-2005
02:05 PM
MOT FOR ISSUANCE OF COMMISSION     24-MAY-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 03-05054703 PLTFS' UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR ISSUANCE OF COMMISSION FILED
 
24-MAY-2005
12:32 PM
MOTION ASSIGNED     24-MAY-2005
12:32 PM
Docket Entry: 43-05054643 MOTION TO COMPEL ASSIGNED TO JUDGE ACKERMAN ON 5-25-05
 
24-MAY-2005
02:07 PM
MOTION ASSIGNED     24-MAY-2005
02:07 PM
Docket Entry: 03-05054703 MOTION FOR ISSUANCE OF COMMISSION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE ACKERMAN ON 5-25-05
 
03-JUN-2005
10:10 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   03-JUN-2005
10:13 AM
Docket Entry: 03-05054703 IT IS ORDERED THAT THE PROTHONOTARY ISSUE A COMMISSION AUTHORIZING THE CLERK OF THE COURTS OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS TO ISSUE PROCESS AND COMPEL THE TEXTIMONY AND PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS BY ROBERT J. MCCUNNEY, M.D. AND ROBERT CHARPIE, M.D. ...BY THE COURT; ACKERMAN, J. 5-25-05
 
14-JUN-2005
03:06 PM
MOT FOR ISSUANCE OF COMMISSION     15-JUN-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 43-05064143 RESPONSE DATE: 6-27-05 (FILED BY PLTFS)
 
27-JUN-2005
11:47 AM
ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED     29-JUN-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 43-05064143 ANS TO PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR ISSUANCE OF A COMMISSION FILED BY DEFENDANTS.
 
29-JUN-2005
03:53 PM
REPLY FILED     29-JUN-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 43-05064143 PLTFS' REPLY FILED IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ISSUANCE OF COMMISSION
 
29-JUN-2005
04:23 PM
MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED     29-JUN-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 43-05064143 MOTION FOR ISSUANCE OF A COMMISSION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE ACKERMAN ON 6-30-05.
 
30-JUN-2005
01:33 PM
MOTION/PETITION/STIP WITHDRAWN     30-JUN-2005
01:35 PM
Docket Entry: 43-05054643 MOTION TO COMPEL WITHDRAWN
 
05-JUL-2005
03:16 PM
MOTION TO COMPEL     05-JUL-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 08-05074008 RESPONSE DATE: 7-12-05 (FILED BY PLTFS)
 
06-JUL-2005
11:03 AM
MOTION TO STRIKE     08-JUL-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 40-05074040 RESPONSE DATE: 7-18-05. FILED BY PLAINTIFFS.
 
06-JUL-2005
11:08 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN ACKERMAN, NORMAN   06-JUL-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 43 05064143 AND NOW, THIS 1ST DAY OF JULY, 2005, UPON CONSIDERATION OF PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR THE ISSUANCE OF A COMMISSION TO SUBPOENA DOCUMENTS IN OHIO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT THE PROTHONOTARY ISSUE A COMMISSION AUTHORIZING THE CLERK OF THE COURTS OF THE STATE OF OHIO TO ISSUE PROCESS AND COMPEL THE PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS BY BRUSH WELLMAN, INC...... BY THE COURT: JUDGE NORMAN ACKERMAN
 
13-JUL-2005
10:50 AM
MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED     13-JUL-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 08-05074008 MOTION TO COMPEL ASSIGNED TO JUDGE ACKERMAN ON 7-14-05
 
14-JUL-2005
10:02 AM
REPLY FILED     15-JUL-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 08-05074008 PLTFS' REPLY FILED IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO COMPEL
 
18-JUL-2005
10:38 AM
ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED     19-JUL-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 40-05074040 ANS FILED TO MOTION TO STRIKE (FILED BY DEFT, NGK NORTH AMERICA)
 
19-JUL-2005
11:01 AM
MOTION ASSIGNED     19-JUL-2005
11:01 AM
Docket Entry: 40-05074040 MOTION TO STRIKE ASSIGNED TO JUDGE ACKERMAN ON 7-20-05
 
28-JUL-2005
11:29 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN BERNSTEIN, MARK I   28-JUL-2005
11:36 AM
Docket Entry: 40-05074040 & 074008 IT IS ORDERED THAT DOCTOR MCCUNNEY'S OBJECTIONS TO THE SUBPOENA FILED IN THIS COURT ARE OVERRULED WITH CERTAIN EXCEPTIONS. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. WITH RESPECT TO THE MOTION TO COMPEL DEFT, CABOT CORP TO IDENTIFY DOCUMENTS RESPONSIVE TO PLTF'S SECOND REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS THE FOLLOWING ORDER IS ENTERED: WITH RESPECT TO REQUESTS #6-#16 AND #19-#24, COUNSEL FOR SAID DEFT SHALL WITHIN 10 DAYS HEREOF PRODUCE TO PLTF'S COUNSEL A STATEMENT AS TO THEIR ELECTION TO IDENTIFY THE DOCUMENT ALREADY PRODUCED WHICH ARE RESPONSIVE TO THOSE REQUESTS OR ALTERNATIVELY TO DECLINE TO IDENTIFY, IN WHICH CASE THEY ARE ORDERED TO PAY PLTF ALL REASONABLE COSTS INCURRED IN REVIEWING ALL DOCUMENTS IN THEIR OFFFICE AND ALL REASONABLE COSTS INCURRED IN QUESTIONING THE DEPONENT OR DEPONENTS ABOUT DOCUMENTS TO WHICH THEY CANNOT REASONABLY ASCERTAIN WHETHER OR NOT THEY ARE RESPONSIVE. COUNSEL ARE FURTHER DIRECTED TO PROVIDE THE COURT BY LETTER, ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF ACTIVITY TAKEN AND DECISIONS MADE PURSUANT TO THIS ORDER. BY THE COURT ...BERNSTEIN,J 7/27/05
 
02-NOV-2005
12:04 PM
STENOGRAPHER'S NOTES FILED     02-NOV-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: ONE VOLUME(S) OF NOTES TAKEN ON 8-23-05 BEFORE JUDGE MARK I BERNSTEIN.
 
05-DEC-2005
03:35 PM
CERTIFICATION FILED     06-DEC-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: CERTIFICATE PREREQUISITE TO SERVICE OF SUBPOENAS PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.22 FILED.
 
23-DEC-2005
03:25 PM
MOTION TO COMPEL     30-DEC-2005
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 15-05125215 RESPONSE DATE: 1-3-06. MOTION FILED BY PLAINTIFF'S.
 
09-JAN-2006
01:15 PM
MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED     09-JAN-2006
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 15-05125215 MOTION TO COMPEL ASSIGNED TO JUDGE PANEPINTO ON 1-10-06.
 
13-JAN-2006
10:19 AM
ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED     17-JAN-2006
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 15-05125215 ANS FILED TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL. FILED BY DEFENDANT NGK INSULATORS, LTD.
 
23-JAN-2006
04:29 PM
REPLY FILED     24-JAN-2006
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 15-05125215 REPLY FILED TO DEFENDANTS ANS TO MOTION TO COMPEL. FILED BY PLAINTIFFS.
 
06-FEB-2006
03:10 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN PANEPINTO, PAUL P   06-FEB-2006
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 15-05125215 IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT A RULE RETURNABLE IS ENTERED ON DEFENDANT NGK INSULATORS TO SHOW CAUSE WHY PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL DEFENDANT TO PRODUCE ELECTRONIC DOCUMENTS, ADDITIONAL CORPORATE WITNESS AND FOR SANCTIONS SHOULD NOT BE GRANTED. RULE RETURNABLE THE 9TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2006 AT 2:30 P.M. IN COURTROOM 696, CITY HALL, PHILADELPHIA, PA. PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL TO SERVE ALL PARTIES WITH A COPY OF THIS RULE. ...BY THE COURT; PANEPINTO, J. 2-6-06
 
06-MAR-2006
11:15 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN PANEPINTO, PAUL P   06-MAR-2006
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 15 06125215 AND NOW, THIS 6TH DAY OF MARCH, 2006, UPON CONSIDERATIO OF PLAINTIFFS' MOTION TO COMPEL NGK INSULATORS, LTD. TO PRODUCE ELECTRONIC DOCUMENTS, TO PRODUCE ADDITIONAL CORPORATE WITNESSES FOR DEPOSITIONS AND FOR SANCTIONS, DEFENDANT'S RESPONSE THERETO, AND AFTER ARGUMENT IN OPEN COURT, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AS FOLLOWS: 1. PLAINTIFFS' MOTION TO COMPEL NGK INSULATORS, LTD. TO PRODUCE ELECTRONIC DOCUMENTS IS GRANTED. THE PARTIES ARE DIRECTEDA TO SUBMIT TO THIS COURT WITHIN THIRTY (30) DAYS OF ENTRY OF THIS ORDER AN AGREED UPON CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER DETAILING THE MANNER IN WHICH ELECTRONIC DOCUMENTS SHALL BE PRODUCED; 2. PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO PRODUCE ADDITIONAL CORPORATE WITNESSES FOR DEPOSITIONS IS DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO PLAINTIFFS' RIGHT TO RE-FILE SAID MOTION AFTER THE PRODUCTION OF SAID ELECTRONIC DOCUMENTS; 3. PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR SANCTION IS DENIED.....BY THE COURT: JUDGE PAUL P. PANEPINTO
 
22-JUN-2006
12:28 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN PANEPINTO, PAUL P   22-JUN-2006
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #8 ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...PANEPINTO,J 6/20/06
 
03-JUL-2006
12:04 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN PANEPINTO, PAUL P   03-JUL-2006
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: REVISED CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #8 ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...PANEPINTO,J 7/3/06
 
18-SEP-2006
01:31 PM
MOTION TO COMPEL     18-SEP-2006
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 43-06094343 RESPONSE DATE: 9-25-06. MOTION FILED BY PLAINTIFFS.
 
28-SEP-2006
11:46 AM
MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED     28-SEP-2006
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 43-06094343 MOTION TO COMPEL ASSIGNED TO JUDGE PANEPINTO ON 9-29-06.
 
03-OCT-2006
10:58 AM
ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED     04-OCT-2006
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 43-06094343 ANS FILED TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL. FILED BY DEFENDANTS.
 
06-OCT-2006
04:03 PM
MOTION/PETITION/STIP WITHDRAWN     09-OCT-2006
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 43-06094343 MOTION TO COMPEL WITHDRAWN PER LETTER. FILED BY ATTY, STEPHAN MATANOVIC.
 
20-MAR-2007
11:05 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN PANEPINTO, PAUL P   20-MAR-2007
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #9 ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...PANEPINTO,J 3/19/07
 
28-MAR-2007
01:47 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN PANEPINTO, PAUL P   28-MAR-2007
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #10 ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...PANEPINTO,J 3/28/07
 
22-JUN-2007
11:00 AM
WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE     25-JUN-2007
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: WITHDRAWAL OF APPEARANCE OF PATRICK W KITTREDGE AND THERESA HUYNHLANZDORF ON BEHALF OF NGK NORTH AMERICA INC. FILED.
 
10-SEP-2007
11:20 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN TERESHKO, ALLAN L   10-SEP-2007
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: STIPULATION TO EXTEND DISCOVERY DEADLINE OR PURPOSE OF TAKING CERTAIN DEPOSITIONS ENTERED. SEE STIPULATION FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...TERESHKO,J 9/7/07
 
08-NOV-2007
04:20 PM
EMERGENCY MOTION/PET FILED     09-NOV-2007
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 06-07114006 DEFENDANTS EMERGENCY MOTION TO COMPEL PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS FILED:
 
08-NOV-2007
04:37 PM
ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED     09-NOV-2007
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 06-07114006 PLAINTIFFS ANSWER IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS EMERGENCY MOTION TO COMPEL PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS FILED:
 
13-NOV-2007
09:13 AM
MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED     13-NOV-2007
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 06-07114006 EMERGENCY MOTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE TERESHKO ON 11-13-2007:
 
13-NOV-2007
11:26 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN TERESHKO, ALLAN L   13-NOV-2007
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 06-7114006 IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT DEFENDANTS' EMERGENCY MOTION TO COMPEL PRODUCTION OF PAPER IDENTIFIED IN EXPERT DISCLOSURES IS GRANTED. PLAINTIFFS' COUNSEL IS DIRECTED TO IMMEDIATELY PRODUCE A COPY OF THE UNPUBLISHED DRAFT PAPER TO DEFENSE COUNSEL OF RECORD. SEE ORDER FOR FULL TERMS AND CONDITIONS. ....BY THE COURT: TERESHKO. J. 11-13-07
 
14-NOV-2007
11:10 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN TERESHKO, ALLAN L   14-NOV-2007
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: REVISED CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #10 ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR COMPLETE TERMS. BY THE COURT ...TERESHKO,J 11/13/07
 
20-NOV-2007
03:39 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN TERESHKO, ALLAN L   20-NOV-2007
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: IT IS ORDERED THAT, UPON CONSIDERATION OF DEFTS' EMERGENCY MOTION TO COMPEL PRODUCTION, PLTFS' COUNSEL IS DIRECTED TO IMMEDIATELY PRODUCE A COPY OF THE UNPUBLISHED DRAFT PAPER TO DEFENSE COUNSEL OF RECORD IN THIS LITIGATION SUBJECT TO CERTAIN LIMITATIONS. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...TERESHKO,J 11/20/07
 
06-DEC-2007
04:14 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN TERESHKO, ALLAN L   06-DEC-2007
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: AND NOW, THIS 4TH DAY OF DECEMBER, 2007, UPON CONSIDERATION OF THE AGREEMENT REACHED AMONG THE PARTIES CONCERNING THE PRODUCTION OF A PAPER IDENTIFIED IN EXPERT DISCLOSURES OF PLAINTIFFS' EXPERT CRAIG STEVEN GLAZER, M.D., THE COURT MAKES THE FOLLOWING FINDINGS AND DIRECTS THE FOLLOWING ACTIONS: 1. THE SCIENTIFIC PAPER IN QUESTION, "MAKING THE DIAGNOSIS OF OCCUPATIONAL ASTHUMA: WHEN TO SUSPECT IT AND WHAT TO DO", IS AN UNPUBLISHED PAPER IN WHICH THE PROFESSIONAL JURANL PRIMARY CARE HAS A COPYRIGHT INTEREST, HAVING ACCEPTED SAME FOR PUBLICATION ON A DATE THAT WILL OCCUR AFTER DR. GLAZER IS DEPOSED ON DECEMBER 13, 2007 IN THIS LITIGATION; 2. PLAINTIFFS' COUNSEL IS DIRECTED TO IMMEDIATELY PRODUCE A COPY OF THE UNPUBLISHED PAPER TO DEFENSE COUNSEL OF RECORD IN THIS LITIGATION SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING LIMITATIONS: A. NO PARTY RECEIVING A COPY OF THIS UNPUBLISHED PAPER SHALL REPRODUCE OR DISSEMINATE IT IN ANY MANNER AND FOR ANY PURPOSE NOT APPROVED HEREIN OR OTHERWISE BY THE AGREEMENT OF COUNSEL; B. THE UNPUBLISHED PAPER SHALL BE USED FOR THE LIMITED PURPOSE OF THIS LITIGATION AND NO OTHER PURPOSE, AND SHALL NOT BE SHARED WITH ANY PERSON OR OTHER ENTITY APART FROM COUNSEL RECEIVING THE COPY AS COUNSEL OF RECORD, THOSE PERSONS WITHIN COUNSELS' FIRMS WHO ARE SPECIFICALLY CHARGED WITH WORKING ON THIS LITIGATION, THOSE PERSONS RETAINED BY COUNSEL AS EXPERTS IN CONNECTION WITH THIS LITIGATION AND COUNSELS' CLIENTS. IT IS SO ORDERED...BY THE COURT: JUDGE ALLAN L. TERESHKO
 
11-DEC-2007
11:49 AM
MISCELLANEOUS MOTION/PETITION     12-DEC-2007
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 11-07124211 PLAINTIFFS' EMERGENCY MOTION TO COMPEL PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO THE EXPERT REPORT, AND UPCOMING DEPOSTIONS OF MICHAEL A. KELSH, PH.D AND RENEE M. KALMES, MSPH, CIH OF EXPONENT HEALTH SCIENCES, A CONSULTANT ON CORPORATE HEALTH ISSUES RETAINED BY DEFENDANT NGK INSULATORS, LTD. FILED:
 
12-DEC-2007
12:06 PM
MOTION ASSIGNMENT UPDATED     12-DEC-2007
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 11-07124211 EMERGENCY MOTION ASSIGNED TO JUDGE TERESHKO ON 12-12-2007:
 
21-DEC-2007
11:04 AM
ANSWER (MOTION/PETITION) FILED     26-DEC-2007
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 11-07124211 ANSWER OF DEFENDANT NGK INSULATORS LTD TO PLAINTIFFS EMERGENCY MOTION TO COMPEL:
 
02-JAN-2008
01:03 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN TERESHKO, ALLAN L   02-JAN-2008
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 11-07124211 AND NOW THIS 2 DAY OF JANUARY 2008, UPON CONSIDERATION OF DEFENDANT, NGK INSULATORS, LTD'S (INSULATORS), REPLY TO PLAINTIFFS' EMERGENCY MOTION TO COMPEL PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO THE EXPERT REPORT, AND UPCOMING DEPOSITION OF MICHAEL A. KELSH, PH.D. AND RENEE M. KAMES, MSPH, CIH OF EXPONENT HEALTH SCIENCES, A CONSULTANT ON CORPORATE HEALTH ISSUES RETAINED BY DEFENDANT NGK INSULATORS, LTD. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT SAID MOTION IS DENIED. ....BY THE COURT: TERESHKO, J. 1-02-08
 
04-JAN-2008
02:45 PM
CERTIFICATION FILED     09-JAN-2008
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: CERTIFICATE PREREQUISITE TO SERVICE OF SUBPOENAS PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.22 FILED.
 
12-FEB-2008
11:57 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN TERESHKO, ALLAN L   12-FEB-2008
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: ORDER BY AGREEMENT: WITH THE AGREEMENT OF ALL PARTIES, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT THIS COURT'S ORDER OF NOV.13,2007 AND THE REVISED ORDER BY AGREEMENT DATED NOV. 20,2007, BOTH PERTAINING TO THE PAPER ENTITLED "RECENT COMMUNITY ACQUIRED CHRONIC BERYLLIUM DISEASE IN RESIDENTS SURROUNDING A BERYLLIUM FACILITY" CO-AUTHORED BY PLAINTIFFS' EXPERT JOHN W. MARTYNY, Ph.D.,ARE HEREBY VACATED....APPROVED BY THE COURT: TERESHKO,J...2/12/2008.
 
25-MAR-2008
10:30 AM
MOTION TO COMPEL HONIK, RUBEN   02-APR-2008
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: 33-08030833 RESPONSE DATE 4-1-2008: MOTION TO COMPEL PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS PURSUANT TO A SUBPOENA AND TO FIND BRUSH WELLMAN, INC. IN CONTEMPT OF COURT:
 
02-APR-2008
10:33 AM
MOTION ASSIGNED     02-APR-2008
10:33 AM
Docket Entry: 33-08030833 MOTION TO COMPEL ASSIGNED TO JUDGE TERESHKO ON 4-2-2008:
 
03-APR-2008
02:31 PM
MOTION/PETITION/STIP WITHDRAWN     03-APR-2008
02:31 PM
Docket Entry: 33-08030833 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT WITHDRAWN PER STEPHEN MATANOVIC ESQ.
 
01-MAY-2008
01:16 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN TERESHKO, ALLAN L   01-MAY-2008
12:00 AM
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_113.pdf
 
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #11 ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...TERESHKO,J 5/1/08
 
25-JUL-2008
10:20 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN TERESHKO, ALLAN L   25-JUL-2008
12:00 AM
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_114.pdf
 
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #12 ENTERED. SEE ORDER. BY THE COURT ...TERESHKO,J 7/24/08
 
02-OCT-2008
03:18 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN TERESHKO, ALLAN L   02-OCT-2008
12:00 AM
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_115.pdf
 
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #14 ENTERED. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...TERESHKO,J 10/2/08
 
03-OCT-2008
11:40 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN TERESHKO, ALLAN L   03-OCT-2008
12:00 AM
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_116.pdf
 
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #13 ENTERED REGARDING MEDIATION OF STITZEL CASE. SEE ORDER FOR TERMS. BY THE COURT ...TERESHKO,J 10/3/08
 
08-DEC-2008
10:13 AM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN TERESHKO, ALLAN L   08-DEC-2008
12:00 AM
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_117.pdf
 
Docket Entry: AND NOW, ON THIS 5TH DAY OF DECEMBER, 2008, UPON THE AGREEMENT OF THE PARTIES, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DECREED THAT CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER NO. 13, ENTERED IN THIS MATTER ON OCTOBER 2, 2008, IS HEREBY REVISED AND AMENDED AS SET FORTH BELOW: 1. DEPOSITION OF EXPERTS DESIGNATED BY PLAINTIFFS FOR TRIAL IN THE ABOVE-REFERENCED CASE SHALL BE PERMITTED AND PLAINTIFFS SHALL PROVIDE DATES TO DEFENDANTS FOR THE EXPERT DEPOSITIONS OF THEIR EXPERTS WITHIN 14 DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. DEPOSITIONS OF PLAINTIFFS' EXPERTS AS SET FORTH IN THIS PARAGRAPH SHALL OCCUR AND BE COMPLETED NO LATER THAN JANUARY 23, 2009. THE PARTIES SHALL AGREE UPON A MANNER FOR SHARING FEES AND EXPENSES OF EACH EXPERT FOR PURPOSES OF DEPOSITION. 2. DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS SHALL BE FILED BY THE PARTIES IN THE ABOVE-REFERNECE CASE ON OR BEFORE FEBRUARY 6, 2009. ANY RESPONSE TO A DISPOSITIVE MOTION SHALL BE FILED AND SERVED WITHIN 21 DAYS AFTER THE MOTION IS FILED. ANY REPLY TO RESPONSE SHALL BE FILED AND SERVED WITHIN 10 DAYS AFTER THE RESONSE IS FILED. 3. FRYE MOTIONS AS TO ANY EXPERTS DESIGNATED BY PLAINTIFFS SHALL BE FILED BY THE DEFENDANTS ON OR BEFORE FEBRUARY 13, 2009. ANY RESPONSE TO FRYE MOTION SHALL BE FILED AND SERVED BY PLAINTIFFS WITHIN 20 DAYS AFTER THE MOTION IS FILED. THE COURT SHALL THEREAFTER ESTABLISH A DATE FOR FRYE HEARINGS AND WITNESS TESTIMONY AS THE COURT DETERMINES NECESSARY. IN ALL OTHER RESPECTS, THE COURT'S CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER NO. 13 REMAINS UNCHANGED... BY THE COURT: JUDGE ALLAN L. TERESHKO
 
11-FEB-2009
12:44 PM
ORDER ENTERED/236 NOTICE GIVEN MOSS, SANDRA M   11-FEB-2009
12:00 AM
Documents:
Click link(s) to preview/purchase the documents
ORDER_118.pdf
 
Docket Entry: CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER NO. 15: AND, NOW THIS 11TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2009, IT IS ORDERED AND DECREED AS FOLLOWS: 1. SUBSTANTIAL DISCOVERY HAVING BEEN CONDUCTED OVER THE COURSE OF SEVERAL YEARS BETWEEN AND AMONG SOME OR ALL OF THE PARTIES HERETO, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT ALL DISCOVERY TAKEN IN THE FOLLOWING BERYLLIUM LITIGATION, MAY BE USED AS IF TAKEN IN ANY AND ALL CASES IN THIS PROGRAM: CONRAD V. NGK METALS CORP.,, ETAL, E.D. PA. NO. 00-CV-2441; DONDORE V. NGK METALS, CORP., ETAL., E.D.PA. NO. 00-CV-1966; DEBIEC V. NGK METALS CORP., E.D.PA. NO. 01-CV-2614; RUSSO V. NGK METALS CORP., ETAL., E.D.PA. NO. 01-CV-2613 BRANCO V. NGK METALS CORP., ETAL., E.D.PA. NO. 01-CV-2775; REESER V. NGK METALS CORP., ETAL., E.D.PA. NO. 01-CV-2776; ANTHON V. NGK METALS CORP., ETAL., E.D. PA. NO 01-CV-3669; KOCH V. NGK METALS CORP., ETAL., E.D. PA. NO. 01-CV-5187; VITALO V. NGK METALS CORP., ETAL E.D. PA. NO. 01-CV-6729; SHERIDAN V. CABOT CORP., E.D,. PA. NO. 02-CV-1212; SHERIDAN, ETAL V. NGK METALS CORP., ETAL., E.D. PA. NO. 06-CV-05510; POHL V. NGK METALS CORP., ETAL., NO. 03070733 COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF PHILADELPHIA COUNTY; IN RE BERYLLIUM LITIGATION, NO. 03110002, COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF PHILADELPHIA COUNTY, AND ALL INDIVIDUAL CASES THEREIN; MORGANTI V. CABOT CORP., APRIL TERM 2002, NO. 2721 BY THE COURT: JUDGE SANDRA M. MOSS
 
24-AUG-2011
10:39 AM
ACTIVE CASE     24-AUG-2011
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: none.
 
18-NOV-2011
02:16 PM
DISPOSED - CASE CLOSED     18-NOV-2011
12:00 AM
Docket Entry: THE BERYLLIUM LITIGATION MASS TORT PROGRAM HAS CONCLUDED. ACCORDINGLY, THIS MASTER DOCKET IS CLOSED. SXT...11-18-2011.



Case Description Related Cases Event Schedule Case Parties Docket Entries